© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Corrosion Testing — Practice 149<br />
8.3.3 MEAN ACCELERATION RATIOS AND COEFFICIENT<br />
OF VARIATION<br />
Another interesting approach to evaluating field data versus accelerated data is the<br />
mean acceleration ratio and coefficient of variation [37].<br />
To compare data from a field exposure to data from an accelerated test for a set<br />
of panels, the acceleration ratio for each type of material (i.e., coating and substrate)<br />
is calculated <strong>by</strong> dividing the average result from the accelerated test <strong>by</strong> the corresponding<br />
reference value, usually from field exposure. These results are then<br />
summed up for all the panels in the set and divided <strong>by</strong> the number of panels in the<br />
set to give the mean acceleration ratio. That is,<br />
Where:<br />
MVQ is the mean value of quotients<br />
X i,accel is the response (creep from scribe) from the accelerated test for each sample i<br />
X i,field is the response from field exposure for each sample i<br />
n is the number of samples in the set [37, 38]<br />
This is used to normalize the standard deviation <strong>by</strong> dividing it <strong>by</strong> the mean value<br />
(MVQ):<br />
The coefficient of variation combines the amount of acceleration provided <strong>by</strong><br />
the test with how uniformly the corrosion is accelerated for a set of samples. It is<br />
desirable, of course, for an acceleration test to accelerate the corrosion rate more or<br />
less uniformly for all the samples; that is, the standard deviation should be as low<br />
as possible. It follows naturally that the ratio of deviation to mean acceleration should<br />
be as close to 0 as possible. A high coefficient of variation means that, for each set<br />
of data, there is more spread in the amount of acceleration than there is actual<br />
acceleration.<br />
8.4 SALT SPRAY TEST<br />
n Xi<br />
accel<br />
∑ X<br />
,<br />
i=<br />
1 i, field<br />
MVQ = + / − σ<br />
n<br />
Coefficent of variation =<br />
The salt spray (fog) test ASTM B117 (‘‘Standard Practice for Operating Salt Spray<br />
(Fog) Testing Apparatus”) is one of the oldest corrosion tests still in use. Despite a<br />
widespread belief among experts that the salt spray test is of no value in predicting<br />
<strong>©</strong> <strong>2006</strong> <strong>by</strong> <strong>Taylor</strong> & <strong>Francis</strong> <strong>Group</strong>, <strong>LLC</strong><br />
Test accel MVQ t<br />
. = ⋅<br />
t<br />
n−1<br />
σn−1 MVQ<br />
field<br />
accel