a tripartite report - Unctad
a tripartite report - Unctad
a tripartite report - Unctad
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
196 VOLUNTARY PEER REVIEW OF CLP: A TRIPARTITE REPORT ON THE UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA – ZAMBIA – ZIMBABWE<br />
the United Republic of Tanzania and Zambia. This<br />
scenario is highly capable of triggering staff turnover<br />
and other human resources problems, hence<br />
immediate prompt remedy is called for to normalize<br />
the situation especially considering the fact<br />
that the Zimbabwean economy is recovering and<br />
creating more demand for competition related interventions.<br />
It was also learnt that CTC have attempted to<br />
raise pay of its staff, but the procedure is too bureaucratic<br />
that the Minister of Trade must consult<br />
the Minister of Finance for approval of pay rise<br />
for staff of the CTC. This not only robs the independence,<br />
given to CTC by ZCA in Section 3, but<br />
also demonstrates the myriad powers that Ministers<br />
have over CTC functions. The implication<br />
of such statutory provisions is that even in the<br />
<br />
it shall still have to struggle with approvals of the<br />
two Ministers.<br />
There is limited use of ICT and electronic documentation<br />
of proceed and archives that may lead<br />
to avoidable delays in implementation of activities<br />
at the CTC. There is no website and just recently<br />
CTC have managed to establish its own domain<br />
of emails.<br />
According to the interviewed staff, CTC does not<br />
ing<br />
with ICT; the CTC has signed service contracts<br />
mand<br />
for a full time person to manage ICT then<br />
the Commission will recruit one such person, add-<br />
iting<br />
factor to having such facilities as prudence<br />
may require.<br />
<br />
funds to carry out the broad mandate it has been<br />
statutorily given. Table 1 below shows that merger<br />
<br />
the CTC followed by Trade Development Levy 198 .<br />
CTC operates with a budget of less than a million<br />
<br />
compared to its counterpart in the United Repub-<br />
<br />
an increase in the budget of the CTC is strongly<br />
recommended, it needs, however to be noted<br />
that comparing the CTC’s budget directly with the<br />
competition authority of the United Republic of<br />
Tanzania might be misleading since unlike the latter,<br />
the Zimbabwean authority does not have ex-<br />
tensive consumer protection functions, which take<br />
up a lot of resources.<br />
Table 1: Commission’s Income Source Since<br />
2010<br />
Source<br />
2010<br />
(Actual)<br />
($)<br />
2011<br />
(Actual)<br />
($)<br />
2012<br />
(Estimate)<br />
($)<br />
Government Grant 114 154 210 405 319 000<br />
<br />
Fees<br />
154 986 267 402 368 450<br />
Trade Development<br />
Levy<br />
657 620 205 986 200 000<br />
Investment Income 0 42 683 50 000<br />
Sundry Income 1 211 5 492 -<br />
Total 927 971 731 969 937 450<br />
Source: CTC<br />
As per section 23, CTC receives money from Parliamentary<br />
allocation, fees and other sources any<br />
other moneys that may vest in or accrue to the<br />
Commission, whether in terms of the ZCA or otherwise<br />
(emphasis by the author). This can be con-<br />
sistent<br />
with the spirit and objectives of the ZCA;<br />
it needs to be limited to issues consistent to the<br />
ZCA.<br />
There is evidence that regulatory authorities have<br />
excess money that emanate from their regulatory<br />
functions. Other jurisdictions (United Republic of<br />
Tanzania and Turkey) have statutorily provided in<br />
their competition laws that they shall receive funds<br />
from the regulated sectors authorities. These would<br />
be examples worth emulating so as to boost CTC<br />
coffers in a bid to have the competition frontier<br />
pushed forward in tandem with the regulated sectors.<br />
This reemphasizes the need to have the need<br />
to have the relationship with the regulated sectors<br />
<br />
competition and sector regulator’s laws.<br />
3.8.2 Caseload<br />
The CTC <strong>report</strong>s on cases that have been handled<br />
to mean all those that have been initiated irrespective<br />
of their closure. Table 2 below summa-<br />
<br />
the years. 199