01.06.2013 Views

a tripartite report - Unctad

a tripartite report - Unctad

a tripartite report - Unctad

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

196 VOLUNTARY PEER REVIEW OF CLP: A TRIPARTITE REPORT ON THE UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA – ZAMBIA – ZIMBABWE<br />

the United Republic of Tanzania and Zambia. This<br />

scenario is highly capable of triggering staff turnover<br />

and other human resources problems, hence<br />

immediate prompt remedy is called for to normalize<br />

the situation especially considering the fact<br />

that the Zimbabwean economy is recovering and<br />

creating more demand for competition related interventions.<br />

It was also learnt that CTC have attempted to<br />

raise pay of its staff, but the procedure is too bureaucratic<br />

that the Minister of Trade must consult<br />

the Minister of Finance for approval of pay rise<br />

for staff of the CTC. This not only robs the independence,<br />

given to CTC by ZCA in Section 3, but<br />

also demonstrates the myriad powers that Ministers<br />

have over CTC functions. The implication<br />

of such statutory provisions is that even in the<br />

<br />

it shall still have to struggle with approvals of the<br />

two Ministers.<br />

There is limited use of ICT and electronic documentation<br />

of proceed and archives that may lead<br />

to avoidable delays in implementation of activities<br />

at the CTC. There is no website and just recently<br />

CTC have managed to establish its own domain<br />

of emails.<br />

According to the interviewed staff, CTC does not<br />

ing<br />

with ICT; the CTC has signed service contracts<br />

mand<br />

for a full time person to manage ICT then<br />

the Commission will recruit one such person, add-<br />

iting<br />

factor to having such facilities as prudence<br />

may require.<br />

<br />

funds to carry out the broad mandate it has been<br />

statutorily given. Table 1 below shows that merger<br />

<br />

the CTC followed by Trade Development Levy 198 .<br />

CTC operates with a budget of less than a million<br />

<br />

compared to its counterpart in the United Repub-<br />

<br />

an increase in the budget of the CTC is strongly<br />

recommended, it needs, however to be noted<br />

that comparing the CTC’s budget directly with the<br />

competition authority of the United Republic of<br />

Tanzania might be misleading since unlike the latter,<br />

the Zimbabwean authority does not have ex-<br />

tensive consumer protection functions, which take<br />

up a lot of resources.<br />

Table 1: Commission’s Income Source Since<br />

2010<br />

Source<br />

2010<br />

(Actual)<br />

($)<br />

2011<br />

(Actual)<br />

($)<br />

2012<br />

(Estimate)<br />

($)<br />

Government Grant 114 154 210 405 319 000<br />

<br />

Fees<br />

154 986 267 402 368 450<br />

Trade Development<br />

Levy<br />

657 620 205 986 200 000<br />

Investment Income 0 42 683 50 000<br />

Sundry Income 1 211 5 492 -<br />

Total 927 971 731 969 937 450<br />

Source: CTC<br />

As per section 23, CTC receives money from Parliamentary<br />

allocation, fees and other sources any<br />

other moneys that may vest in or accrue to the<br />

Commission, whether in terms of the ZCA or otherwise<br />

(emphasis by the author). This can be con-<br />

sistent<br />

with the spirit and objectives of the ZCA;<br />

it needs to be limited to issues consistent to the<br />

ZCA.<br />

There is evidence that regulatory authorities have<br />

excess money that emanate from their regulatory<br />

functions. Other jurisdictions (United Republic of<br />

Tanzania and Turkey) have statutorily provided in<br />

their competition laws that they shall receive funds<br />

from the regulated sectors authorities. These would<br />

be examples worth emulating so as to boost CTC<br />

coffers in a bid to have the competition frontier<br />

pushed forward in tandem with the regulated sectors.<br />

This reemphasizes the need to have the need<br />

to have the relationship with the regulated sectors<br />

<br />

competition and sector regulator’s laws.<br />

3.8.2 Caseload<br />

The CTC <strong>report</strong>s on cases that have been handled<br />

to mean all those that have been initiated irrespective<br />

of their closure. Table 2 below summa-<br />

<br />

the years. 199

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!