29.12.2013 Views

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Rein (1975) investigated the effects of fibre and pol % cane on the extraction achieved by<br />

milling tandems, by using a statistical approach. He showed that extraction is adversely<br />

affected by high fibre levels but improves as pol % cane rises.<br />

A cost analysis done by Cargill (1976) showed the following:<br />

• Reducing tops and trash in cane by 3% would increase throughput (tons cane per hour<br />

TCH) by 9% with the same installed capacity, and reduce transport costs by 3%.<br />

• Decreasing trash in cane by 1% would increase the overall recovery of pol by 0.3%.<br />

Scott (1977) carried out full-scale tests at two milling tandems to measure the effect of<br />

fibre % cane, trash and tops in cane on throughput. Except for tops in cane, he obtained<br />

statistically significant regressions:<br />

TCH = 203.3 – 5.3 fibre % cane<br />

TCH = 134.3 – 3.0 trash % cane<br />

The overall results showed that the crushing rate is reduced by about 4% for a unit rise in<br />

fibre % cane and by 2.2 to 3.0% for a unit rise in trash % cane.<br />

Reid and Lionnet (1989) carried out full-scale processing of different types of harvested<br />

cane: clean stalk, stalk without removal of tops, trash, and tops and trash. Compared to<br />

clean stalk, the results showed that:<br />

• The mill throughput with unburnt, untopped cane was 30% less than that with burnt,<br />

topped cane, while that with unburnt, topped cane was 22% less.<br />

• Compared to burnt, topped cane, boiling house recovery was predicted to drop by 6%<br />

with unburnt, untopped cane.<br />

Similar results were obtained when Lionnet (1992b) carried out tests with a diffuser<br />

instead of the milling tandems.<br />

The effect of trash on milling has been studied by numerous workers. Most of the studies<br />

either dealt with dry trash only or a fixed pre-defined proportion of dry trash, cane tops and<br />

soil, while many others were conducted as factory trials. Using an experimental threeroller<br />

mill equipped with rollers of 10 inches diameter and 14 inches long with a hydraulic<br />

pressure of 30 tons, Arceneaux and Davidson (1944) crushed clean cane of several<br />

varieties to which were added separately green and dry trash in amounts of 2.5, 5.0 and<br />

7.5%, with maceration water applied four times at 20% on the cane. They found that green<br />

21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!