Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov
Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov
Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
1.1.3 GREAT LAKES REGION<br />
1.1.3.1 State of New York<br />
Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic<br />
In the Northeast, the Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic (ca. 10,000 B.P. to 8,000 B.P. <strong>and</strong> ca. 8,000 B.P.<br />
to 6,000 B.P., respectively) have come to be primarily defined in terms of<br />
climatic/environmental transition. During these times, the ecological setting transformed from<br />
immediate post-glacial tundra <strong>and</strong> spruce-park forests through denser spruce-fir, pine-oak, <strong>and</strong><br />
deciduous oak-hemlock forests to an essentially modern oak-hickory forest system (Funk,<br />
1983:304-305; Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:171-172). As is the case for the Paleo-Indian period,<br />
archaeological sites from the Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic have mostly been identified by the<br />
presence of diagnostic projectile points, including Hi-Lo, Kanawha Stemmed, Kirk, LeCroy<br />
Bifurcated Stem, MacCorkle, Palmer, Raddatz Side-Notched, <strong>and</strong> St. Albans Side-Notched<br />
points (Abel <strong>and</strong> Fuerst 1999:12-13; Calkin <strong>and</strong> Miller 1977:309; Justice 1995:44-46, 54-58, 67-<br />
69, 71-79, 81-85, 86-96). Many of these point types have characteristic bifurcated bases.<br />
Relatively few Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic sites have been found in New York (Funk, 1978:20).<br />
The low frequency of sites probably correlates with small populations, even relative to earlier<br />
Paleo-Indian levels (Fitting, 1978a:14; Funk, 1983:316-319; Griffin, 1983:248; Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk<br />
2006:193). These low population levels may be related to a minimally-productive environment;<br />
for example “coniferous forests with their low carrying capacity for deer <strong>and</strong> other game<br />
constituted an unfavorable environment for hunters <strong>and</strong> gatherers” (Funk, 1978:23; Calkin <strong>and</strong><br />
Miller, 1977:309; cf. Nicholas, 1987:100-105). However, many sites probably remain to be<br />
found in less-studied areas, since the post-glacial environment in the Northeast was not<br />
uniformly desolate <strong>and</strong> included highly productive diverse environments like “lakes, ponds,<br />
extensive wetl<strong>and</strong>s, <strong>and</strong> emergent riverine systems” that formed in the basins of former glacial<br />
lakes (Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:193; Nicholas, 1987:105-106).<br />
Many Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic sites in the Northeast cluster on former glacial lakes (Nicholas,<br />
1987:106). In the Susquehanna Valley in New York (just outside the study area), Early Archaic<br />
projectile point forms have been found in both upl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> valley floors (Funk, 1993:317). The<br />
Zawatski Site, an Early Archaic site in western New York, was situated on the floodplain of the<br />
Allegheny River in Cattaraugus County (Calkin <strong>and</strong> Miller, 1977:310-312), suggesting that an<br />
Early Archaic preference towards occupation on valley floors was not confined to the<br />
Susquehanna (cf. Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:193).<br />
In general, there is meager direct evidence concerning Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic subsistence,<br />
site types, <strong>and</strong> tool assemblages (with the exception of projectile points) in New York (Abel <strong>and</strong><br />
Fuerst, 1999:13; Funk, 1993:258-265). The Havil<strong>and</strong> site, located in a relic me<strong>and</strong>er of<br />
Cobleskill Creek in Schoharie County, New York is a rare example of an excavated Early<br />
Archaic lithic workshop (Ferguson, 1995). Artifacts from the site include Kanawha bifurcatebase<br />
projectile points, thin bifacial ovate knives, thin unifacial tools, cores, hammerstones,<br />
debitage, abraders, anvils, choppers, <strong>and</strong> pitted stones. Middle Archaic tool kits are more<br />
extensive than those from the Early Archaic <strong>and</strong> include pecked <strong>and</strong> ground stone items (axes,<br />
adzes, gouges, celts, mortars, pestles, plummets, <strong>and</strong> netsinkers), polished tools such as<br />
Northern Border Activities H-19 July 2012