06.09.2014 Views

Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov

Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov

Appendix H - Historical Archaeological and ... - CBP.gov

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

1.1.3 GREAT LAKES REGION<br />

1.1.3.1 State of New York<br />

Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic<br />

In the Northeast, the Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic (ca. 10,000 B.P. to 8,000 B.P. <strong>and</strong> ca. 8,000 B.P.<br />

to 6,000 B.P., respectively) have come to be primarily defined in terms of<br />

climatic/environmental transition. During these times, the ecological setting transformed from<br />

immediate post-glacial tundra <strong>and</strong> spruce-park forests through denser spruce-fir, pine-oak, <strong>and</strong><br />

deciduous oak-hemlock forests to an essentially modern oak-hickory forest system (Funk,<br />

1983:304-305; Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:171-172). As is the case for the Paleo-Indian period,<br />

archaeological sites from the Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic have mostly been identified by the<br />

presence of diagnostic projectile points, including Hi-Lo, Kanawha Stemmed, Kirk, LeCroy<br />

Bifurcated Stem, MacCorkle, Palmer, Raddatz Side-Notched, <strong>and</strong> St. Albans Side-Notched<br />

points (Abel <strong>and</strong> Fuerst 1999:12-13; Calkin <strong>and</strong> Miller 1977:309; Justice 1995:44-46, 54-58, 67-<br />

69, 71-79, 81-85, 86-96). Many of these point types have characteristic bifurcated bases.<br />

Relatively few Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic sites have been found in New York (Funk, 1978:20).<br />

The low frequency of sites probably correlates with small populations, even relative to earlier<br />

Paleo-Indian levels (Fitting, 1978a:14; Funk, 1983:316-319; Griffin, 1983:248; Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk<br />

2006:193). These low population levels may be related to a minimally-productive environment;<br />

for example “coniferous forests with their low carrying capacity for deer <strong>and</strong> other game<br />

constituted an unfavorable environment for hunters <strong>and</strong> gatherers” (Funk, 1978:23; Calkin <strong>and</strong><br />

Miller, 1977:309; cf. Nicholas, 1987:100-105). However, many sites probably remain to be<br />

found in less-studied areas, since the post-glacial environment in the Northeast was not<br />

uniformly desolate <strong>and</strong> included highly productive diverse environments like “lakes, ponds,<br />

extensive wetl<strong>and</strong>s, <strong>and</strong> emergent riverine systems” that formed in the basins of former glacial<br />

lakes (Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:193; Nicholas, 1987:105-106).<br />

Many Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic sites in the Northeast cluster on former glacial lakes (Nicholas,<br />

1987:106). In the Susquehanna Valley in New York (just outside the study area), Early Archaic<br />

projectile point forms have been found in both upl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> valley floors (Funk, 1993:317). The<br />

Zawatski Site, an Early Archaic site in western New York, was situated on the floodplain of the<br />

Allegheny River in Cattaraugus County (Calkin <strong>and</strong> Miller, 1977:310-312), suggesting that an<br />

Early Archaic preference towards occupation on valley floors was not confined to the<br />

Susquehanna (cf. Lepper <strong>and</strong> Funk, 2006:193).<br />

In general, there is meager direct evidence concerning Early <strong>and</strong> Middle Archaic subsistence,<br />

site types, <strong>and</strong> tool assemblages (with the exception of projectile points) in New York (Abel <strong>and</strong><br />

Fuerst, 1999:13; Funk, 1993:258-265). The Havil<strong>and</strong> site, located in a relic me<strong>and</strong>er of<br />

Cobleskill Creek in Schoharie County, New York is a rare example of an excavated Early<br />

Archaic lithic workshop (Ferguson, 1995). Artifacts from the site include Kanawha bifurcatebase<br />

projectile points, thin bifacial ovate knives, thin unifacial tools, cores, hammerstones,<br />

debitage, abraders, anvils, choppers, <strong>and</strong> pitted stones. Middle Archaic tool kits are more<br />

extensive than those from the Early Archaic <strong>and</strong> include pecked <strong>and</strong> ground stone items (axes,<br />

adzes, gouges, celts, mortars, pestles, plummets, <strong>and</strong> netsinkers), polished tools such as<br />

Northern Border Activities H-19 July 2012

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!