You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>IT</strong> HOLDING S.p.A. Notes to the consolidated financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2004<br />
been issued with reference to this last preliminary assessment.<br />
<strong>IT</strong>J S.p.A. (merged into <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. in 2002)<br />
In 2000, this company received from the Regional Tax Office of Campobasso, a preliminary assessment report<br />
relating to the 1997 and 1998 tax periods. The irregularities assessed for 1997 were settled in 2003, as a "potential<br />
dispute" under article 15 of Law no. 289/2002. In the year 2004 a notice of assessment for the year 1998 was<br />
received, against which the company has lodged an appeal with the relevant judicial authorities.<br />
FD S.p.A. (merged into <strong>IT</strong>J S.p.A. in 2001)<br />
With reference to the preliminary assessment report received from the Regional Tax Office of Campobasso<br />
alleging irregularities in terms of form and substance with regard to direct and indirect taxes for the years 1999 and<br />
2000, the company has received a notice of assessment for the year 1999 against which it has lodged an appeal with<br />
the relevant judicial authorities.<br />
The maximum potential tax liability that could arise is estimated to be Euro 2.4 million, however Management,<br />
having heard the opinion of its tax advisors, does not believe it probable that this liability will arise.<br />
Other pending litigation<br />
• On March 23, 1998, Trussardi S.p.A. ("Trussardi") summoned <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. ("<strong>IT</strong>TIERRE") before the<br />
Milan Court, claiming that <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE had breached a license agreement for the “Trussardi Jeans” brand which<br />
expired on June 30, 1996. Trussardi requested a reward for damages from <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. of approximately<br />
Euro 50 million. <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. appeared in court denying it had ever breached the agreement and asked<br />
that the claim be fully dismissed. In December 2004, the Tribunal of Milan decided in favour of Trussardi and<br />
ordered <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. to pay damages of Euro 8.3 million plus interest and court costs. <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A.<br />
has appealed this decision and on February 22, 2005 obtained an injunction suspending payment of these<br />
amounts. Any amount awarded to Trussardi in final judgement would fall within the scope of an indemnity<br />
granted to the Group by PA Investments which agrees to hold the Group harmless against all liabilities and<br />
costs associated with all litigation, arbitration and regulatory proceedings instituted prior to April 28, 2002 and<br />
arising from events that took place prior to December 31, 1996.<br />
• On June 20, 2000, Casor S.p.A. (“Casor”) summoned MAC S.p.A. (MAC), the predecessor of MALO S.p.A.<br />
("MALO") before the Florence Court, claiming that MAC had breached the five-year license agreement signed<br />
between the two companies and that it pay damages amounting to approximately Euro 3.6 million. The<br />
management of MALO S.p.A., having heard their legal advisors, believe the complaint to be unsubstantiated as<br />
they claim never to have entered into a 5 year licence agreement with Casor and hence believe it unlikely that<br />
the dispute will result in adverse judgement.<br />
• A professional previously engaged by MALO S.p.A. for assistance in the creation of certain sales spaces,<br />
summoned MALO S.p.A., before the Rome Court, claiming it had reproduced his innovative design concept in<br />
other sales spaces without respecting the exclusive rights to it and asking the Court to award damages of Euro<br />
462 thousand. MALO S.p.A. appeared and disputed the requests on the grounds of inadmissibility and lack of<br />
grounds. It also included the architectural firm engaged to create the spaces under dispute as a party to the<br />
proceedings. Management believes it unlikely that the dispute will result in adverse judgement.<br />
• Tecnostile S.r.l., a company based in Florence, summoned GIANFRANCO FERRÉ S.p.A., claiming damages<br />
amounting to Euro 620 thousand, arising from pre-contractual obligations. Evidence has been gathered and the<br />
next hearing is scheduled in June 2005, for conclusions to be presented. Management believe it unlikely that<br />
the dispute will give rise to a liability for the company.<br />
• In December 2003 Damap S.r.l. brought two separate actions against <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. and two separate<br />
licensors of <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. for damages allegedly deriving from the breach of a patent on the decorative<br />
model of a specific denim processing used for apparel produced and marketed by <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. The<br />
amount of the claim is equal to Euro 3 million. Management believes the claim to be unfounded and that an<br />
unfavourable outcome appears unlikely. <strong>IT</strong>TIERRE S.p.A. has also brought a cross-claim against the<br />
manufacturer of the denim fabric in question.<br />
F- 44