14.11.2012 Views

185000000 IT Holding Finance SA

185000000 IT Holding Finance SA

185000000 IT Holding Finance SA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

compensation for damages. Our agreement with the purchaser of our shares in Gigli S.p.A. requires us to<br />

indemnify such purchaser against all liabilities arising in relation to this specific pending litigation. However, we<br />

believe that an unfavorable outcome appears unlikely.<br />

In January 2004, an attorney brought an action against <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A., Ittierre S.p.A. and Diners Club Italia<br />

S.p.A., claiming fees of €3.3 million for legal work in connection with the drafting of certain financial agreements<br />

among these three companies. <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. and Ittierre S.p.A. deny having engaged the claimant or that any<br />

fees, if any, would exceed €25,000. We believe that this claim is unfounded and that an unfavorable outcome<br />

appears unlikely.<br />

In August 2002, Mr. Luigi Giribaldi asked the Tribunal of Isernia to reexamine the two third-party appraisals<br />

conducted in connection with the acquisition by <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. of Gianfranco Ferré S.p.A. on the basis that<br />

such appraisals were not conducted by independent third-party appraisers. We believe that Mr. Giribaldi’s claims<br />

are unfounded. A decision by the Tribunal of Isernia is expected during the first half of 2005.<br />

We have been informed of an action before the Tribunal of Milan that Mr. Luigi Giribaldi brought against PA<br />

Investments in December 2001 in which Mr. Giribaldi has requested enforcement of an oral contract with PA<br />

Investments whereby PA Investments agreed to acquire Mr. Giribaldi’s entire shareholding in <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A.<br />

PA Investments has denied the existence of any such oral agreement with Mr. Giribaldi. It should be noted that <strong>IT</strong><br />

<strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. is not a party to this dispute and in any event benefits from an indemnity granted to us by PA<br />

Investments. Therefore, we believe that this matter does not give rise to any risk of financial liabilities for us.<br />

In October 2004, we disposed of Allison S.p.A. At the time of this disposal, an action was pending against Allison<br />

in the arbitral court of Treviso brought by a supplier who alleged that Allison had breached the terms of a supply<br />

agreement and claimed damages in the amount of approximately €7.0 million. The arbitral court in a preliminary<br />

award rejected Allison’s claims that the supply agreement was void. A final arbitral award will be issued by<br />

August 31, 2005. In connection with our sale and purchase agreement, we agreed to indemnify the purchaser<br />

against any losses arising from outstanding litigation (including this arbitral proceeding).<br />

In August 2004, certain companies, including <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. and Servizi Moda S.r.l., were served a petition for<br />

urgent relief put forth by Mr. Romeo Gigli and Romeo Gigli s.a.s. Mr. Gigli claims that he is owed at least €41.0<br />

million on account of future amounts receivable, damages for alleged breach of contract, and fees accrued and not<br />

received. Accordingly, he requested the Tribunal of Milan to order provisional remedies to protect his current and<br />

future claims with respect to all companies involved, including <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. and Servizi Moda S.r.l. On<br />

September 8, 2004, the Tribunal of Milan rejected all the requests made by the petitioners. The petitioners<br />

appealed this decision and on December 13, 2004, the Tribunal of Milan denied this appeal. In January 2005 Mr.<br />

Gigli and Romeo Gigli s.a.s commenced a proceeding on the merits against <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Holding</strong> S.p.A. before the Tribunal<br />

of Milan, asking for damages in the amount of approximately €47.0 million in connection with essentially the same<br />

claims described above. The first hearing in this case has been scheduled for May 17, 2005.<br />

Tecnostile S.r.l., a company based in Florence, has brought an action against Gianfranco Ferré S.p.A. claiming<br />

damages of approximately €620,000 in respect of alleged pre-contractual obligations. Evidence has been gathered<br />

and the next hearing has been scheduled for June 2005. We believe that it is unlikely that this dispute will give rise<br />

to a liability for the defendant.<br />

36

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!