FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICScircumcised primarily by trained, ritualproviders in nonmedical settings,and reported similarly low c<strong>om</strong>plicationrates. The overall c<strong>om</strong>plicationrate was 0.34%, including bleeding in0.08% and infection in 0.01%. 183 Approximatelyone-third of the identifiedc<strong>om</strong>plications were immediate (ie,bleeding, infection, penile injury),whereas two-thirds occurred later (ie,excess foreskin, penile torsion, shortageof skin, phimosis, inclusion cyst).There is fair evidence of a more frequentc<strong>om</strong>plication rate of 3.1% ina study based on abstraction of 1951hospital medical (rather than billing)records on newborn circumcision inAtlanta. 184 In this study, c<strong>om</strong>plicationswere found to be much more c<strong>om</strong>mon,with bleeding occurring in 2.1%,although most reports of bleedingwere mild in nature. Likewise, a reviewwith fair evidence of 1000 newborncircumcisions by using theG<strong>om</strong>co clamp in a hospital setting inSaudi Arabia found an overall c<strong>om</strong>plicationrate of 1.9%. 185 Bleeding occurredin 0.6%, infection in 0.4%, andredundant prepuce in 0.3%.Late c<strong>om</strong>plications of newborn circumcisioninclude excessive residualskin (inc<strong>om</strong>plete circumcision), excessiveskin removal, adhesions (naturaland vascularized skin bridges),meatal stenosis, phimosis, and epithelialinclusion cysts. These c<strong>om</strong>plicationsare considered “late,” asopposed to “acute” (or immediate)c<strong>om</strong>plications such as bleeding orinfection, which may still presentduring infancy but not during the immediatepostprocedural time frame.In 1 outpatient-based study of 214boys with poor evidence, the c<strong>om</strong>plicationsseen included adhesions (observedin 55 boys [25.6%]), redundantresidual prepuce (44 boys [20.1%]),balanitis (34 boys [15.5%]), skinbridge (9 boys [4.1%]), and meatalstenosis (1 boy [0.5%]). 76Outside the United States, a crosssectionalstudy fr<strong>om</strong> Nigeria of 370consecutive male infants (322 ofwh<strong>om</strong> had been circumcised) attendingan infant welfare clinic forimmunization with fair evidencereported an overall c<strong>om</strong>plication rateof 20.2%. 186 C<strong>om</strong>plications includedredundant prepuce (12.9%), excessiveskin removal (5.9%), skin bridge(4.1%), and buried penis (0.4%). Themajority of the procedures (81%)were performed in the hospital; 19%were performed at h<strong>om</strong>e. Nursesperformed 56% of procedures (n =180), physicians performed 35% (n =113), and traditional circumcisersperformed 9% (n = 29). The Israelistudy noted earlier with fair evidencereported a late c<strong>om</strong>plicationof redundant prepuce in 0.2% of the19 478 male infants studied. 183There is good evidence that circumcisionof a premature infant isassociated with an increased risk oflater-occurring c<strong>om</strong>plications (ie, poorcosmesis, increased risk of trappedpenis, adhesions). There is also goodevidence that circumcision of a newbornwho has a pr<strong>om</strong>inent suprapubicfat pad or penoscrotal webbing hasa higher risk for the same long-termc<strong>om</strong>plications. 187 One prospectivestudy with fair evidence examined thenatural course of penile adhesions<strong>af</strong>ter circumcision and found thatadhesions disappeared at s<strong>om</strong>e point6 months postcircumcision withoutintervention, except for thick adhesions(called “bridging adhesions”).The authors rec<strong>om</strong>mended lysis forskin bridges. 188Post-newborn CircumcisionThere have been few reports of acutec<strong>om</strong>plications <strong>af</strong>ter non-newborn circumcisionin the United States. Furthermore,there are no adequatestudies of late c<strong>om</strong>plications inboys undergoing circumcision in thepost-newborn period; this area requiresmore study.Although adverse outc<strong>om</strong>es are rareamong non-newborn circumcisions,the incidence tends to be orders ofmagnitude greater for boys circumcisedbetween 1 and 10 years of age,c<strong>om</strong>pared with those circumcised asnewborns. 189 As noted, general anesthesia,which is used for proceduresperformed <strong>af</strong>ter the newborn period,confers additional risk.The most c<strong>om</strong>mon surgical c<strong>om</strong>plicationis excessive bleeding (eg, bleedingthat did not stop with local pressure,perhaps requiring a suture), reportedin 0.6% of 1742 male infants. 184 Contactburns were reported with electrocauterywhen used with metal, and itshould not be used with the G<strong>om</strong>coclamp in newborn circumcisionsbecause it can cause devastatingburns. 184,190,191 A study with fair evidencereviewed the records of 476boys undergoing circumcision duringchildhood and found that c<strong>om</strong>plicationsoccurred in 8 records (1.7%), ofwhich 3 were related to anesthesia. 192The most c<strong>om</strong>mon surgical c<strong>om</strong>plicationwas excessive bleeding in 0.6%.In another report with fair evidence,which examined 267 patients whohad circumcision by using topicalglue rather than skin sutures, excessivebleeding occurred in 0.75% ofcases. 193European centers report an overallc<strong>om</strong>plication rate of 1.2% to 3.8% forcircumcisions performed in boysduring the newborn or non-newbornperiod. 194–196 In a study with fair evidenceof trained medical personnel inthe United Kingd<strong>om</strong>, the rate ofbleeding was 0.8% and of infectionwas 0.3%. In this study of a historicalcohort of over 75 boys aged 0 to 14years, 0.5% required surgical repair.195In a Turkish prospective cohort studyof 700 boys with fair evidence, bleedingPEDIATRICS Volume 130, Number 3, September 2012Downloaded fr<strong>om</strong> pediatrics.aappublications.org by guest on June 19, 2013e773
was reported in 2.2% of cases andinfection in 1.3% of boys circumcisedin a hospital, versus a bleeding rate of3.6% and an infection rate of 2.7% inboys undergoing a nonhospital-basedmass religious procedure, despitethe latter procedure being performedby trained personnel. 196There are no adequate analytic studiesof late c<strong>om</strong>plications in boys undergoingcircumcision in the post-newborn period.An Iranian cross-sectional studywith good evidence reported a latec<strong>om</strong>plication rate of 7.4%, includingredundant skin in 3.6%, excessive skinremoval in 1.3%, and meatal stenosisin 0.9%. 197Major C<strong>om</strong>plicationsThe majority of severe or even catastrophicinjuries are so infrequent asto be reported as case reports (andwere therefore excluded fr<strong>om</strong> thisliterature review). These rare c<strong>om</strong>plicationsinclude glans or penile amputation,198–206 transmission of herpessimplex <strong>af</strong>ter mouth-to-penis contactby a mohel (Jewish ritual circumcisers)<strong>af</strong>ter circumcision, 207–209 methicillinresistantStaphylococcus aureus infection,210 urethral cutaneous fistula, 211glans ischemia, 212 and death. 213Medical Versus Traditional ProvidersIn general, untrained providers createmore c<strong>om</strong>plications when performingmale circumcision than dowell-trained providers, regardless ofwhether they are physicians, nurses, ortraditional religious providers. Physiciansin a hospital setting generallyhave fewer c<strong>om</strong>plications than traditionalproviders in the c<strong>om</strong>munitysetting.A prospective study in Kenya with goodevidence found an overall c<strong>om</strong>plicationrate of 35% in 443 children and youngmen aged 5 to 21 years who hadtraditional circumcision performed ina village or household setting, c<strong>om</strong>paredwith an overall c<strong>om</strong>plicationrate of 17% in those whose circumcisionwas performed by trained providersin a medical setting such asa hospital, health center, or physician’soffice. 214 The most c<strong>om</strong>mon c<strong>om</strong>plicationswere bleeding and infection;excessive pain, lacerations, torsion,and erectile dysfunction were alsoobserved. A study in Turkey with fairevidence studied a historical cohortand found a significantly higher rate ofc<strong>om</strong>plications when male circumcisionwas performed by traditional circumcisers,c<strong>om</strong>pared with those performedby physicians; c<strong>om</strong>plicationrates were 85% for traditional providersversus 2.6% for physicians. 215A study in Israel with fair evidencefound there was no difference in therate of c<strong>om</strong>plications in newborncircumcision between hospital-basedphysicians and well-trained, h<strong>om</strong>ebasedritual circumcisers (mohels). 183C<strong>om</strong>plications With Different Methodsof Male CircumcisionThere have been few studies c<strong>om</strong>paringthe 3 most c<strong>om</strong>monly usedtechniques for male circumcision inthe United States (the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp,the Plastibell device, and the Mogenclamp). Steps c<strong>om</strong>mon to all 3 includeestimation of the amount of externalskin to be removed; dilation of thepreputial orifice so the glans can bevisualized to ensure that the glans itselfis normal; bluntly freeing the innerpreputial epithelium fr<strong>om</strong> the epitheliumof the glans; placing the device;leaving the device in place long enoughto produce hemostasis; and surgicallyremoving the foreskin.G<strong>om</strong>co ClampThe G<strong>om</strong>co clamp was specificallydesigned for performing circumcisions.In this procedure, “the foreskinis cut lengthwise through thestretched tissue (dorsal slit) to allowspace to insert the circumcision device.The bell of the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp isplaced over the glans, and the foreskinis pulled over the bell. The baseof the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp is placed over thebell, and the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp’s arm isfitted. After the surgeon confirmscorrect fitting and placement (and theamount of foreskin to be excised), thenut on the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp is tightenedand left in place for 3 to 5 minutes toallow hemostasis to occur, then theforeskin is removed using a scalpel.The G<strong>om</strong>co’s base and bell are thenremoved.” 216One study of the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp with fairevidence reviewed 1000 newborn circumcisionsin a hospital setting inSaudi Arabia and found an overallc<strong>om</strong>plication rate of 1.9%. 185 Bleedingoccurred in 0.6% of cases, infection in0.4%, and redundant prepuce in 0.3%.Another study of 521 newborn malecircumcisions performed at a Houstonoutpatient clinic with fair evidencereported a 2.9% incidence of phimosis(trapped penis) <strong>af</strong>ter newborn circumcisionusing the G<strong>om</strong>co clamp. 217Plastibell DevicePlastibell circumcision involves a surgicalprocedure in which a plastic ringis inserted under the foreskin, anda tie is placed over the ring to providehemostasis. The ring remains on thepenis for several days until the tissuenecroses and the ring falls off spontaneously.Bleeding ranged fr<strong>om</strong> 0.8% to3% of cases; infection occurred in 2.1%of cases. 218 Urinary retention 219,220 andproblems with the Plastibell ring havebeen reported in 3.6% of cases. 221Studies of the Plastibell device with fairand good evidence found, overall, thatc<strong>om</strong>plications range fr<strong>om</strong> 2.4% to5%. 218,221–223Mogen ClampThe Mogen clamp is a device consistingof 2 flat blades that have a limitede774FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICSDownloaded fr<strong>om</strong> pediatrics.aappublications.org by guest on June 19, 2013
- Page 1 and 2:
OMSKÆRINGAF DRENGENotat2013
- Page 3 and 4:
Indhold1 Sundhedsstyrelsens sammenf
- Page 5 and 6:
1 Sundhedsstyrelsens sammenfatningO
- Page 7 and 8:
døgn under indlæggelse på sygehu
- Page 9 and 10:
arnet ligger på en pude på et bor
- Page 11 and 12:
se områder i Afrika. WHO understre
- Page 13 and 14:
3 Omskæring i DanmarkFor en del å
- Page 15 and 16:
Hvis en person, der hverken er læg
- Page 17 and 18: 4 Omskæring i andre landEfter Sund
- Page 19 and 20: sundhedsmæssige fordele ikke er tu
- Page 21: 6 Bilagsfortegnelse:Bilag 1:Sundhed
- Page 24 and 25: WHITEPAPER- OM RITUEL OMSKÆRELSE A
- Page 26 and 27: OM RITUEL JØDISK OMSKÆRELSE AF DR
- Page 29 and 30: White Paper om religiøs omskærels
- Page 31 and 32: har været oppe med jævne mellemru
- Page 33 and 34: To tredjedel færre infektioner på
- Page 35 and 36: Der er en betydelig risiko for, at
- Page 37 and 38: 2.3 Beskrivelse af afrapporteringen
- Page 39 and 40: 3.5 Betydningen for den jødiske fa
- Page 41 and 42: af medicinske årsager, hvoraf alvo
- Page 43 and 44: lodtrækning fik foretaget omskære
- Page 45 and 46: Endvidere skal lægen i fornødent
- Page 47 and 48: Stritøreoperationer udføres både
- Page 49 and 50: Den foreliggende medicinske forskni
- Page 51 and 52: TECHNICAL REPORTMale Circumcisionab
- Page 53 and 54: principle on which each of thesedev
- Page 55 and 56: FIGURE 2Prevalence of male circumci
- Page 57 and 58: TABLE 2 Results from Medline, Cochr
- Page 59 and 60: Male Circumcision and Diseases,Morb
- Page 61 and 62: een diagnosed with genital herpes a
- Page 63 and 64: Results data indicate that the inci
- Page 65 and 66: participants’ ages and any coexis
- Page 67: without general anesthesia in boys
- Page 71 and 72: nurse practitioners) should workcol
- Page 73 and 74: circumcision practices in theUnited
- Page 75 and 76: at: www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/facts
- Page 77 and 78: childhood: a meta-analysis. Pediatr
- Page 79 and 80: multicenter survey. Isr Med Assoc J
- Page 81 and 82: Male CircumcisionTASK FORCE ON CIRC
- Page 83 and 84: The online version of this article,
- Page 85 and 86: COMMENTARYIn this commentary, a dif
- Page 87 and 88: COMMENTARYThe cardinal medical ques
- Page 89 and 90: Cultural Bias in the AAP's 2012 Tec
- Page 91 and 92: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 93 and 94: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 95 and 96: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 97 and 98: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 99 and 100: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 101 and 102: Weiss et al. BMC Urology 2010, 10:2
- Page 103 and 104: 2013-06-21 Dnr x.x-xxxxx/xxxx 1(4)T
- Page 105 and 106: SOCIALSTYRELSEN 2013-06-21 Dnr 3(4)