Download - FDCL
Download - FDCL
Download - FDCL
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
104<br />
4.3 Brazil, foreign direct investment in GATS-2000 and the demands of the<br />
European Commission<br />
In the negotiations on services the Brazilian side and the EU-commission agree<br />
on their definitions of services, in analogy to the four kinds of GATS, where the<br />
topic of investment as Mode 3 includes the treatment of foreign branches of service<br />
companies. 303 But regardless of the existing relatively lax legislation which Brazil<br />
imposes on foreign investors, the European Commission in its “GATS-Requests” in<br />
the framework of GATS-2000 has demanded far reaching liberalization measures for<br />
investment in the area of services. 304 Even if the European Commission has explicitly<br />
asserted in the introductory text to the GATS-2000 Request from the EC and its<br />
Member States (hereafter the EC) to Brazil that:<br />
“the EC is not seeking the dismantling of public services nor the privatization<br />
of state owned companies”, 305<br />
as the procurement of public goods is not to be abolished, but to be commercialized<br />
and opened up to foreign corporations, especially European ones. The<br />
GATS with its broad regulatory framework concerning liberalization is to guarantee<br />
this. And in any case Brazil will have to continue to privatize state enterprises due to<br />
the pressure of the IMF and the practical constraints resulting from its debt-trap. 306<br />
According to the contract made by the former government FHC with the IMF,<br />
which gives way for new credit lines up to 30 billion US-dollars, and which has been<br />
renewed under the same conditions by the Lula-government, Brazil has to reach<br />
an annual primary budget surplus of 4.25%: The politically controlled component of<br />
the Lula-government, from a macroeconomic point of view, consists of making cuts<br />
to the government budget, that is to cut state spending at a high social cost, 307 as<br />
well as the obligation to generate currency earnings through exports, and finally to<br />
303 See Maria Silvia Portella de Castro: Mercosul e União Européia: relações econômicas e comercias e as negociações<br />
do Acordo de Cooperação Inter-Regional, January 2003, p. 35.<br />
304 There are no details available on the requests of the European Commission to Brazil and the MERCOSUR within<br />
the framework of the negotiations on the “association treaty”, except for the avowal of the EU to treat the issue of<br />
“investment” in analogy to the Doha-agenda of the WTO.<br />
305 GATS-2000 Request from the EC and its Member States (hereafter the EC) to Brazil, p. ii., http://www.gatswatch.org/<br />
docs/offreq/EUrequests/Brazil.pdf.<br />
306 See the IMF website at: http://www.imf.org/external/np/loi/2003/bra/04/index.htm: “Brazil - Letter of Intent”,<br />
November 21, 2003: “This Letter of Intent of the government of Brazil describes the policies that Brazil intends to<br />
implement in the context of its request for financial support from the IMF.”<br />
307 See: PAULO NOGUEIRA BATISTA JR. (USP / FGV-EAESP): DIRETO AO PONTO, in: Agência Carta Maior,<br />
December 16, 2003: “O superávit primário passou de 3,5% do PIB em 2000 para 3,6% em 2001, 4% em 2002<br />
e 4,3% em 2003.” Own translation: “The primary surplus rose from 3.5% of GDP in 2000 to 3.6% in 2001, 4% in<br />
2002 and 4.3% in 2003.”