32 ENGAGING YOUNG PEOPLE?Me Dad wants me to get it [apprenticeship] and me Mam said <strong>the</strong>y’ll bedelighted if I get it, because <strong>the</strong>re’s no one in it, my dad’s a qualified painter like,so, me bro<strong>the</strong>rs haven’t really got any trades, me sister’s, yeah she’s, she wasworking as an assistant secretary or something like that for, where I’m notsure…So it’d be a great achievement. (Andrew, 21, completed LCA,apprentice)In cases where older siblings had gone on to fur<strong>the</strong>r education <strong>the</strong>reappeared to be a positive impact on respondents’ post-school pathways. At<strong>the</strong> time <strong>of</strong> interview Linda was studying in an Institute <strong>of</strong> Technology. Shewas influenced by her bro<strong>the</strong>r who had gone to college and had given heradvice on what to do:My bro<strong>the</strong>r, he done university for seven years, he works in Dublin, accountant,he does, he works in a finance place in Dublin, he’s a manager <strong>the</strong>re like, andyeah, he done really well. And <strong>the</strong>n <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>rs all do different jobs like, tiling andyou know, stuff like that, you know. I’d say [bro<strong>the</strong>r’s name] got <strong>the</strong> mosteducation out <strong>of</strong> everyone. (Linda, 21, completed LCA, student)To summarise, <strong>the</strong> analyses shown in this section indicate that LCAparticipants have quite a distinctive pr<strong>of</strong>ile compared to students enteringo<strong>the</strong>r <strong>Leaving</strong> <strong>Certificate</strong> programmes. They are much more likely to befrom working-class, semi/unskilled manual households and tend to havesimilar educational and occupational aspirations to <strong>the</strong>ir parents andsiblings. The next section explores LCA student pr<strong>of</strong>ile in more detail byanalysing <strong>the</strong> types <strong>of</strong> students who take LCA and <strong>the</strong> motivations andinfluences in <strong>the</strong>ir decision making process.4.3Characteristics<strong>of</strong> LCAEntrantsIn order to create typologies <strong>of</strong> students who enter LCA, we identifiedfive types <strong>of</strong> students who take LCA. Respondents are categorisedaccording to <strong>the</strong>ir primary characteristics, although it is acknowledged thatsome have more than one distinguishing feature when entering <strong>the</strong>programme.These include students who:• Struggle with schoolwork at junior cycle;• Have special needs or learning difficulties;• Experience behavioural problems during junior cycle;• Wish to enter <strong>the</strong> labour force;• Feel misdirected in entering LCA.These categories enable an analysis <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong> types <strong>of</strong> students who takeLCA and <strong>the</strong> main pathways into LCA from junior cycle. This allows us toassess whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong> LCA is being taken up by those it was designed for(those at risk <strong>of</strong> early school leaving or underachieving) or if <strong>the</strong> dynamic<strong>of</strong> uptake has changed so that it is now meeting needs it was not originallyintended to meet.
PATHWAYS INTO LCA 334.3.1 STUDENTS WHO STRUGGLE WITH SCHOOLWORK INJUNIOR CYCLEAs might be expected, data from <strong>the</strong> longitudinal survey shows differencesbetween LCA and non-LCA in junior cycle and in particular, that <strong>the</strong> takeup<strong>of</strong> LCA is strongly related to Reading and Ma<strong>the</strong>matics ability on entryto first year (Figure 4.2). Almost a fifth <strong>of</strong> those from <strong>the</strong> lowest readingquintile go on to take LCA compared with 8 per cent <strong>of</strong> those from <strong>the</strong>second lowest quintile and less than 1 per cent from <strong>the</strong> three highestquintiles.Figure 4.2: LCA Take-up by Reading and Maths Ability on Intake2015%1050Lowest Second lowest Middle-highestQuintileReadingComputationSource: Post-Primary Longitudinal Study (PPLS) database.The qualitative interviews also highlight student difficulties with Englishand Ma<strong>the</strong>matics in junior cycle. Half <strong>of</strong> those interviewed described beingweak at <strong>the</strong>se subjects. Justin specified <strong>the</strong> core subjects as <strong>the</strong> areas whichcaused him most difficulty:Mostly Irish and English and that, and Maths, that’s what I found hard.(Justin, 22, completed LCA, employed)Andrew also experienced difficulties with Maths and Irish:Yeah my Maths was very, wouldn’t be <strong>the</strong> greatest and just stuff like that, Mathsand Irish basically, I found it very difficult. (Andrew, 21, completed LCA,apprentice)LCA take-up is also related to <strong>the</strong> streaming <strong>of</strong> classes in junior cycle.Within streamed schools this means that students <strong>of</strong> similar assessed abilityare grouped into classes ranked ‘higher’ to ‘lower’. The longitudinal studyshows that over four in ten <strong>of</strong> those in lower stream classes go on to takeLCA compared with a tenth <strong>of</strong> those in middle stream groups and verysmall proportions <strong>of</strong> those in mixed ability or higher stream classes (Figure4.3). In mixed ability schools, however, LCA entry is not associated withstudents who struggle to keep up with <strong>the</strong> pace <strong>of</strong> instruction. However,since streaming is thought to lead to lower student, and <strong>of</strong>ten teacher