florida state university college of music performance practice

APPENDIX C
SURVEY OF REVIEWS
The following reviews are not meant to be a comprehensive list. Rather the
included reviews serve as a survey of commercial recordings in the past twenty-five
years. Reviews are important in that it provides contemporaneous opinion from reviewers
regarding the reception of a particular recording of a musical work.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Edward Higginbottom,
American Record Guide 67.3 (May/June 2004): 75-76.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Philippe Herreweghe,
American Record Guide 65.3 (May/June 2002): 69-70.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Craig Smith, American
Record Guide 64.5 (September/October 2001): 82-83.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Diego Fasolis, American
Record Guide 62.5 (September/October1999): 94-95.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conductor Karl-Friedrich Beringer,
American Record Guide 61.6 (November/December1998): 88-89.
Althouse, Paul. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Eric Milnes, American Record
Guide 60.2 (March/April 1997): 80-81.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St John Passion, conducted by Frans Brüggen, American
Record Guide 56.6 (November/December 1993): 77-78.
Althouse, Paul. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Fritz Werner and Harry
Christophers, American Record Guide 53.5 September/October 1990): 44-45.
Althouse, Paul L. Review of St. John Passion, conducted by Philippe Herreweghe and
Hermann Scherchen, American Record Guide 51.6 (November/December 1988):
10-11.
Althouse, Paul L. Review for the St. John Passion, conducted by John Eliot Gardiner,
American Record Guide 50.4 & 5 (Fall 1987): 3-4.
Anderson, Nicholas. “A Passion to be different: review of St. John Passion, conducted by
Philippe Herreweghe.” BBC Music Magazine (January 2002): 80.
170