bbc 2015
BBC2015_booklet
BBC2015_booklet
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
BeNeLux Bioinformatics Conference – Antwerp, December 7-8 <strong>2015</strong><br />
Abstract ID: O9<br />
Oral presentation<br />
10th Benelux Bioinformatics Conference <strong>bbc</strong> <strong>2015</strong><br />
O9. DEVELOPMENT OF A DNA METHYLATION-BASED SCORE<br />
REFLECTING TUMOUR INFILTRATING LYMPHOCYTES<br />
Martin Bizet 1,2,3*# , Jana Jeschke 1# , Christine Desmedt 4 , Emilie Calonne 1 , Sarah Dedeurwaerder 1 ,<br />
Gianluca Bontempi 2,3 , Matthieu Defrance 1,2 , Christos Sotiriou 4 and Francois Fuks 1<br />
Laboratory of Cancer Epigenetics, Faculty of Medicine, Université Libre de Bruxelles 1 ; Interuniversity Institute of<br />
Bioinformatics in Brussels, Université Libre de Bruxelles & Vrije Universiteit Brussel 2 ; Machine Learning Group,<br />
Computer Science Department, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels 3 ; Breast Cancer Translational Research<br />
Laboratory, Jules Bordet Institute, Université Libre de Bruxelles 4 ; # These authors contributed equally to this work;<br />
* mbizet@ulb.ac.be<br />
Tumour infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) are increasingly recognised as one of the key feature to predict outcome and<br />
therapy response in malignancies. However, measuring quantities of TIL remains challenging since it relies on subjective<br />
and spatially-restricted measurements from a pathologist. In this study we used genome-scale DNA-methylation profiles<br />
from breast tumours to develop a so-called MeTIL score, which reflects TIL level within whole-tumour samples. We<br />
demonstrate the robustness to noise of the MeTIL score using simulated data as well as the ability of the MeTIL score to<br />
sensitively measure TIL in patient samples and to improve prediction of outcome.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
Breast cancer (BC) is one of the most common and<br />
deadliest diseases in women from Western countries.<br />
Tumour infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) emerged as one of<br />
the key feature to predict outcome and response to<br />
treatment in this disease [ 1 ]. However the measurement of<br />
TIL levels remains challenging because it relies on manual<br />
readings of a tumour cancer slide by a pathologist, which<br />
is subjective by nature and does not necessary reflect the<br />
whole-tumour TIL content. In this study we took<br />
advantage of the high tissue-specificity of DNAmethylation<br />
patterns [ 2 ] to develop a so-called MeTIL<br />
score, which predicts the amount of lymphocytes within<br />
the tumour.<br />
METHODS<br />
The MeTIL score has been developed in 3 key-steps:<br />
We first used genome-scale DNA-methylation<br />
profiles data from 11 cell-lines (8 normal or<br />
cancerous epithelial breast and 3 T-lymphocytes)<br />
to extract 29 cytosines specifically unmethylated<br />
in T-lymphocytes (delta-beta < -0.8 and standard<br />
deviation between groups < 0.1).<br />
We then applied a cross-validated pipeline,<br />
associating mRMR feature selection and randomforest<br />
algorithm, on 118 BC samples to extract a<br />
minimal set of cytosines, which methylation level<br />
is predictive for quantities of TIL.<br />
Finally we used a “normalised PCA” approach to<br />
compute a unique MeTIL score from the<br />
individual methylation values.<br />
The robustness of the relation between the MeTIL score<br />
and TIL levels was also assessed using spearman<br />
correlation computed from 10 000 simulations with<br />
varying proportion of TIL (Fig.1B&C). The simulated<br />
data took two sources of noise into account:<br />
<br />
<br />
Technical noise modeled as a Gaussian noise<br />
Perturbations due to the presence of other celltypes<br />
within the tumour microenvironment that<br />
are not lymphocytic or epithelial, modeled by a<br />
methylation value sampled randomly among the<br />
array.<br />
Lastly, we measured TIL quantities with the MeTIL score<br />
in three independent BC cohorts and applied COX<br />
regression models to evaluate the prognostic value of the<br />
MeTIL score.<br />
RESULTS & DISCUSSION<br />
We first applied a hierarchical clustering analysis and<br />
observed that BC samples with high TIL infiltration show<br />
a hypomethylated pattern for all MeTIL markers (Fig.1A).<br />
Furthermore we demonstrated, using simulations, a strong<br />
correlation between the MeTIL score and TIL levels, even<br />
when high level of noise (0.7 times the standard deviation)<br />
and high proportion of perturbing unknown cell-types<br />
(70%) were included in the model (Fig.1B).<br />
(A)<br />
(C)<br />
(B)<br />
FIGURE 1. The MeTIL score reflects TIL levels (A) Heatmap showing the<br />
methylation values of the 5 MeTIL markers. A ‘TIL high’ group with a<br />
hypomethylated pattern (orange) appeared. (B) Color-map of the<br />
spearman correlation between MeTIL score and TIL level for increasing<br />
noise (y-axis) and abundance of unknown cell-types (x-axis) based on<br />
simulations. (C) Methylation value of each MeTIL marker was simulated<br />
as the sum of the methylation level in lymphocyte (M1), epithelial cell<br />
(M2) and other cell-types (random value M3) weighted by their<br />
proportion in the tissue (f1, f2, f3) and an Gaussian noise (e).<br />
Finally, we observed consistent patterns of TIL levels<br />
within BC subtypes in independent cohorts suggesting the<br />
robust nature of our score to evaluate TIL levels.<br />
Furthermore, COX regressions analysis revealed a<br />
prognostic value for the MeTIL score in triple negative<br />
and luminal BC (p-value < 0.05).<br />
REFERENCES<br />
[ 1 ] Loi, S., et al. Official journal of the European Society for Medical Oncology /<br />
ESMO 25, 1544-1550 (2014).<br />
[ 2 ] Jeschke, J., Collignon, E., Fuks, F. FEBS J., 282, 9:1801-14. (<strong>2015</strong>).<br />
29