23.06.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

A parent has no right to insist upon the pursuit of fruitless dreams of success. There<br />

comes a time when a parent who is a would-be entrepreneur but is unsuccessful<br />

must simply become employed.<br />

[The noncustodial parent] cannot remain unemployed while he lives in an impressive<br />

style and use that lack of employment as an excuse for not paying child support.<br />

Smeal Fire Apparatus Co. v. Kreikemeier, 279 Neb 661, 782 N.W.2d 848 (2010)<br />

This is not a child support case, but it has enormous impact on the world of civil contempt of court.<br />

Although there is no graceful way of retreating from this court's previous rulings,<br />

some of our troubling contempt cases have created needless difficulties at both the<br />

trial and the appellate levels. An untangling of the snarls was long overdue. Our<br />

decision changes the legal landscape of our present contempt law. We overrule a<br />

long line of cases affecting a trial court's jurisdiction, an appellate court's jurisdiction,<br />

and the standard of proof in civil contempt cases.<br />

we overrule cases that have unnecessarily limited a court's inherent and statutorily<br />

granted contempt powers and cases that have precluded appellate review of final<br />

civil contempt orders. These cases' roots run deep. Correcting our contempt<br />

jurisprudence will require extensive pruning.<br />

We hold that in a civil contempt proceeding, a district court has inherent power to<br />

order compensatory relief when a contemnor has violated its order or judgment. We<br />

further hold that whether a contempt sanction is civil or criminal is relevant only<br />

when a party appeals from an interlocutory order of contempt. An interlocutory<br />

contempt order is an order that a court issues during an ongoing proceeding before<br />

the final judgment in the main action.<br />

Finally, we conclude that for future cases, the standard of proof in civil contempt<br />

proceedings is clear and convincing evidence, unless the Legislature has<br />

mandated another standard.<br />

Civil contempt proceedings are '"instituted to preserve and enforce the rights of<br />

private parties to the suit and to compel obedience to orders and decrees made to<br />

enforce the rights and to administer the remedies to which the court has found them<br />

to be entitled . . . , '" Civil contempt proceedings are remedial and coercive in their<br />

nature.<br />

"[T]he power to punish for contempt of court is a power inherent in all courts of<br />

general jurisdiction, . . . independent of any special or express grant of statute."<br />

<strong>Nebraska</strong> courts, through their inherent judicial power, have the authority to do all<br />

things reasonably necessary for the proper administration of justice. And this<br />

authority exists apart from any statutory grant of authority.<br />

Because of the court's continuing equity jurisdiction over the [divorce] decree, the<br />

power to provide equitable relief in a contempt proceeding is particularly<br />

appropriate.<br />

a court cannot modify a dissolution decree in a contempt proceeding absent an<br />

application for a modification and notice that a party seeks modification.<br />

if a complainant seeks, or a court is considering, a modification of the underlying<br />

decree as an equitable sanction for contempt of the court's decree, the alleged<br />

contemnor must first have notice that a modification and a finding of contempt will be<br />

at issue. But when the alleged contemnor has notice and an opportunity to be<br />

heard, a court can modify the underlying decree as a remedy for contempt if the<br />

violation cannot be adequately remedied otherwise.<br />

- 39 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!