20.01.2015 Views

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

19 2 DEBT<br />

<strong>The</strong> same tensions can be observed between neighbors, who in<br />

farming communities tend to give, lend, and borrow things amongst<br />

themselves-anything from sieves and sickles, to charcoal and cooking<br />

oil, to seed corn or oxen for plowing. On the one hand, such giving<br />

and lending were considered essential parts of the basic fabric of human<br />

sociability in farm communities, on the other, overly demanding<br />

neighbors were a notorious irritant-one that could only have grown<br />

worse when all parties are aware of precisely how much it would have<br />

cost to buy or rent the same items that were being given away. Again,<br />

one of the best ways to get a sense of what were considered everyday<br />

dilemmas for Mediterranean peasants is to look at jokes. Late stories<br />

from across the Aegean in Turkey echo exactly the same concerns:<br />

Nasruddin's neighbor once came by ask if he could borrow his<br />

donkey for an unexpected errand. Nasruddin obliged, but the<br />

next day the neighbor was back again-he needed to take some<br />

grain to be milled. Before long he was showing up almost every<br />

morning, barely feeling he needed a pretext. Finally, Nasruddin<br />

got fed up, and one morning told him his brother had already<br />

come by and taken the donkey.<br />

Just as the neighbor was leaving he heard a loud braying<br />

sound from the yard.<br />

"Hey, I thought you said the donkey wasn't here!"<br />

"Look, who are you going to believe" asked Nasruddin.<br />

"Me, or some animal"<br />

With the appearance of money, it could also become unclear what<br />

was a gift, and what a loan. On the one hand, even with gifts, it was<br />

always considered best to return something slightly better than one had<br />

received.78 On the other hand, friends do not charge one another interest,<br />

and any suggestion that they might was sure to rankle. So what's<br />

the difference between a generous return gift and an interest payment<br />

This is the basis of one of the most famous Nasruddin stories, one that<br />

appears to have provided centuries of amusement for peasants across<br />

the Mediterranean basin and adjoining regions. (It is also, I might<br />

note, a play on the fact that in many Mediterranean languages, Greek<br />

included, the word for "interest" literally means "offspring.")<br />

One day Nasruddin's neighbor, a notorious miser, came by<br />

to announce he was throwing a party for some friends. Could<br />

he borrow some of Nasruddin's pots Nasruddin didn't have<br />

many but said he was happy to lend whatever he had. <strong>The</strong> next

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!