20.01.2015 Views

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

Debt: The First 5000 Years - autonomous learning

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

AGE OF THE GREAT CAPITALIST EMPIRES 345<br />

when we're talking about a market in which it is state debts and state<br />

obligations themselves that are being traded; when one cannot really<br />

speak of a state monopoly on force because one is operating in an international<br />

market where the primary currency is bonds that the state<br />

depends on for its very ability to marshal military force<br />

Having made incessant war on all remaining forms of the communism<br />

of the poor, even to the point of criminalizing credit, the masters<br />

of the new market system discovered that they had no obvious justification<br />

left to maintain even the communism of the rich-that level<br />

of cooperation and solidarity required to keep the economic system<br />

running. True, for all its endless strains and periodic breakdowns, the<br />

system has held out so far. But as recent events have dramatically testified,<br />

it has never been resolved.<br />

Part IV:<br />

So What Is Capitalism, Anyway<br />

We are used to seeing modern capitalism (along with modern traditions<br />

of democratic government) as emerging only later: with the Age<br />

of Revolutions-the industrial revolution, the American and French<br />

revolutions-a series of profound breaks at the end of the eighteenth<br />

century that only became fully institutionalized after the end of the Napoleonic<br />

Wars. Here we come face to face with a peculiar paradox. It<br />

would seem that almost all elements of financial apparatus that we've<br />

come to associate with capitalism-central banks, bond markets, shortselling,<br />

brokerage houses, speculative bubbles, securization, annuitiescame<br />

into being not only before the science of economics (which is perhaps<br />

not too surprising), but also before the rise of factories, and wage<br />

labor itself.88 This is a genuine challenge to familiar ways of thinking.<br />

We like to think of the factories and workshops as the "real economy,"<br />

and the rest as superstructure, constructed on top of it. But if this were<br />

really so, then how can it be that the superstructure came first Can the<br />

dreams of the system create its body<br />

All this raises the question of what "capitalism" is to begin with,<br />

a question on which there is no consensus at all. <strong>The</strong> word was originally<br />

invented by socialists, who saw capitalism as that system whereby<br />

those who own capital command the labor of those who do not.<br />

Proponents, in contrast, tend to see capitalism as the freedom of the<br />

marketplace, which allows those with potentially marketable visions<br />

to pull resources together to bring those visions into being. Just about

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!