06.09.2021 Views

American Contract Law for a Global Age, 2017a

American Contract Law for a Global Age, 2017a

American Contract Law for a Global Age, 2017a

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

were to suggest some express provision <strong>for</strong> it in their agreement, they<br />

would testily suppress him with a common “Oh, of course!”<br />

Southern Foundries (1926) Ltd v Shirlaw, [1939] 2 K.B. 206, 227. This definition is<br />

an unusually narrow one, as you may notice upon reading the materials below, but<br />

the basic idea is clear enough. If the parties would reasonably have expected an<br />

unstated term to be part of their agreement, that term will be part of the contract.<br />

Terms Implied from Trade Custom. Many times parties to a contract are part<br />

of a trade or business culture where the members share certain understandings and<br />

have particular ways of doing things. Members of the building trades, <strong>for</strong> example,<br />

understand that when they specify “2 x 4 lumber” they actually mean lumber that is<br />

1.5 inches by 3.5 inches; members of the precious metals trade know that when they<br />

specify “one ounce” of gold they mean one troy ounce, which is smaller than the<br />

everyday English system’s avoirdupois ounce of sixteen to a pound used outside the<br />

arena of precious metals and gemstones. Parties in a particular trade are assumed to<br />

operate again the background of all this trade usage and thus can be assumed to<br />

understand that their contract includes the ordinary terms that are usual in the<br />

trade. If parties wish to avoid trade usage terms, they must do so explicitly.<br />

Default Terms Implied by <strong>Law</strong>. In many situations, the parties have not<br />

addressed an issue, but we do not know what terms these two parties would obviously<br />

have chosen. For example, suppose A contracts to buy B’s car. The parties have not<br />

specified whether the buyer is supposed to pick it up or the seller is supposed to<br />

deliver it. We cannot infer what they each actually intended, and they may now even<br />

disagree about what they intended. Nonetheless, if the seller fails to deliver the car<br />

and the buyer sues, a tribunal will have to decide the issue. In this situation, contract<br />

law has developed what are variously called “background” terms, “gap-filler” terms,<br />

or “default” terms. A default term in contract law—analogous to the default setting<br />

on a computer program—is a term that applies unless the parties elect otherwise.<br />

Thus, in the hypothetical above, the default rule is that when the parties have not<br />

specified otherwise in a sale of goods, the buyer would be responsible <strong>for</strong> picking up<br />

the car, and thus the seller has no obligation to deliver it. See UCC § 2-308(a) (“Unless<br />

otherwise agreed . . . the place <strong>for</strong> delivery of the goods is the seller’s place . . . .”).<br />

Scores of these type of default terms exist in contract law.<br />

Default terms in <strong>American</strong> law are generally set to mimic what most<br />

contracting parties would presumably want in most transactions. There is<br />

considerable scholarly debate about whether this is a good approach to the problem,<br />

and your professor may want to explore the issue with you in more detail. Assuming,<br />

however, that the defaults are set correctly, this system has the advantage of being<br />

more likely (though not certain) to carry out the intent of the particular parties to the<br />

dispute. If you consider the way purchasers usually buy things, <strong>for</strong> example, you will<br />

probably notice that most of the time the buyer picks things up from the seller.<br />

Getting things delivered is less common, and there<strong>for</strong>e a rule that specifies buyer<br />

______________________________________________________________________________<br />

400 CHAPTER VI: TERMS AND INTERPRETATION

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!