20.02.2013 Views

download pdf - Institut für Umweltphysik - Ruprecht-Karls-Universität ...

download pdf - Institut für Umweltphysik - Ruprecht-Karls-Universität ...

download pdf - Institut für Umweltphysik - Ruprecht-Karls-Universität ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

198 CHAPTER 6. FORSCHUNGSSTELLE “RADIOMETRIE”<br />

6.1.8 Isochron dating of fossil reef corals and the reconstruction of past<br />

sea level fluctuations<br />

Participating scientist Denis Scholz, A. Mangini, K. Bohn, T. Felis (Bremen), D. Meischner<br />

(Göttingen)<br />

Abstract We developed an isochron dating approach that enables to derive reliable ages for fossil<br />

reef corals that cannot be dated by the conventional Th/U-method. Isochron dating was applied to<br />

Porites corals from Aqaba and Baja California. In addition, we reconstructed magnitude,timing, and<br />

duration of the Marine Isotope Substage (MIS) 6.5 ( 175,000 years before present) sea level peak by<br />

U-series dating of fossil Acropora palmata corals from Barbados.<br />

Figure 6.7: Isochron dating of coral AQB 3A from<br />

Aqaba. The isochron age is calculated from the intersection<br />

point, the age error is estimated from<br />

the intersection points of the confidence bands.<br />

Background Reconstructions of past sea level<br />

fluctuations allow to determine the magnitude,<br />

timing and duration of glacial/interglacial periods.<br />

This is essential for the understanding of the<br />

causal relationships and the complex interplay between<br />

the forcing and feedback mechanisms in the<br />

climate system.<br />

Some reef coral genera grow in upper 5m below<br />

sea surface only and record past sea level fluctuations.<br />

Thus, the determination of accurate<br />

U-series ages provides a direct method for sea<br />

level reconstruction. Unfortunately, many fossil<br />

reef corals show elevated ( 234 U/ 238 U) activity ratios<br />

which are clear evidence for post-depositional<br />

open-system behaviour. Therefore, conventional<br />

Th/U-ages obtained from such corals cannot be<br />

considered as strictly reliable. There are two possibilities<br />

to deal with this problem: (i) to identify<br />

corals that have not been altered and (ii)<br />

to develop and apply appropriate correction techniques.<br />

Funding BMBF (DEKLIM project)<br />

Methods and results We analysed five fossil<br />

Porites corals from Aqaba, Jordan, by<br />

thermal ionisation mass spectrometry (TIMS).<br />

( 234 U/ 238 U) and ( 230 T h/ 238 U) activity ratios of<br />

Figure 6.8: Sea level reconstruction for MIS 6.5.<br />

Black squares are our coral data from Barbados.<br />

Red and yellow symbols are coral data from other<br />

studies, straight curves are based on oxygen isotopes.<br />

different sub-samples from one coral specimen<br />

show a high linear correlation (Fig. 6.7). This<br />

can be explained by a model assuming different<br />

degree of U addition and subsequent loss for different<br />

sub-samples. The model predicts that the<br />

true coral age can be calculated from the intersection<br />

point of the isochron with the seawater<br />

evolution curve (Fig. 6.7). Isochron dating was<br />

also successfully applied to corals from Baja California,<br />

Mexico [Bohn, 2005].<br />

Detailed investigation of Acropora palmata corals<br />

from Barbados, West Indies, showed that<br />

these corals suffered U-redistribution [Scholz and<br />

Mangini, in press]. Thus, isochron dating cannot<br />

be applied. Careful selection of reliable Th/Uages<br />

by application of strict reliability criteria<br />

suggests that MIS 6.5 sea level ranged from -<br />

50±11 to -47±11 m relative to present sea level<br />

between 176,100±2,800 and 168,900±1,400 years<br />

before present (Fig. 6.8). At present, this reconstruction<br />

is one of the most accurate for MIS 6.5.<br />

Outlook/Future work publication of results<br />

Main publication Scholz et al. [2004], Felis et<br />

al. [2004], Scholz [2005], Bohn [2005], Scholz and<br />

Mangini [in press]

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!