26.10.2013 Views

list of contributors - GALA

list of contributors - GALA

list of contributors - GALA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

COSTA RICA<br />

Uri Weinstok M.<br />

Niehaus & Weinstok<br />

uweinstok@niehauslaw.com<br />

www.niehauslaw.com<br />

1. Proposed<br />

Regulation:<br />

Proposed reform to the General Health Law<br />

Topic: Health related messages<br />

Who: Asamblea Legislativa<br />

When: March 2005<br />

What Happened: The Ministry <strong>of</strong> Health sent an initiative to the Congress (Asamblea<br />

Legislativa), promoting a reform <strong>of</strong> the country’s General Health Law (Ley<br />

General de Salud).<br />

If this reform is approved, all messages that related to public health, or that<br />

in the opinion <strong>of</strong> the authorities may affect public health (including news,<br />

reports, and advertising) will have to be previously cleared for publication<br />

by the Ministry.<br />

Comments: It is very unlikely that an initiative <strong>of</strong> this kind will be approved. However,<br />

the sole fact that it has been sent to Congress tells a lot about the negative<br />

attitude <strong>of</strong> certain authorities towards free speech.<br />

2. Case Report: SMIRNOFF VODKA – “Drink responsibly”<br />

Topic: Alcoholic Beverages<br />

Where: Instituto sobre Alcoholismo y Farmacodependencia (IAFA)<br />

When: December 2004<br />

What Happened: IAFA, the governmental <strong>of</strong>fice in charge <strong>of</strong> reviewing and clearing<br />

advertisements <strong>of</strong> alcoholic beverages rejected an ad for SMIRNOFF<br />

VODKA, because it contained the phrase “Drink responsibly”.<br />

According to IAFA, this phrase is an explicit invitation to drink, disguised as<br />

a warning. The decision stated that only governmental approved warnings<br />

may be included, even if the requested phrase was written in addition to<br />

such warning.<br />

Comments: This case is a good example on how an overzealous regulator may actually<br />

loose the point <strong>of</strong> the real purposes <strong>of</strong> the regulation. These types <strong>of</strong><br />

decisions, which reflect a clear distrust in the industry, are actually impeding<br />

the advertiser from making more responsible marketing.<br />

3. Case Report: Rexona Fresh Intense<br />

Topic: Decency in advertising<br />

Where: Oficina Nacional de Control de Propaganda (ONCP)<br />

When: January 2005<br />

What Happened: This ad <strong>of</strong> a deodorant used different persons in daily activities using body<br />

paint. The paint was very similar to their normal clothes, and was used to<br />

give the impression <strong>of</strong> persons with his/her clothes stuck to their bodies due<br />

to excessive heat, as opposed to the fresh feeling <strong>of</strong> using the said deodorant.<br />

ONCP suspended a TV commercial on the basis that it improperly exposed

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!