29.12.2013 Views

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

310<br />

and his sensuality and this seems to be what Kate does not want.<br />

What is then Lawrence's purpose in marrying this woman with<br />

Cipriano?<br />

Is Kate wishing unconsciously for a communion in the<br />

flesh though she does not realize this? The answer does not<br />

seem clear since Lawrence does not provide it in his narrative.<br />

Kate's marriage to Joachim looks much like Lydia's to Paul<br />

Lensky. Both men are revolutionaries. Their difference lies<br />

perhaps in the fact that Lydia lived through a blind obedience<br />

to Paul's ideals. She did not think by herself. Joachim, on .<br />

the other hand, seems more flexible and Kate does not apparently<br />

complain about the fact that she lived through Joachim.<br />

The<br />

idea one gets, looking at Kate and Joachim's marriage, is that<br />

Kate is a woman who can only love men who are not ordinary, as<br />

Joachim was not:<br />

'...It took me years to understand that a woman<br />

can't love a man - at least a woman like I am<br />

can't - if he is only the sort of good, decent<br />

citizen. With Joachim I came to realise that a<br />

woman like me can only love a man who is<br />

fighting to change the world, to make it freer,<br />

more alive... A woman who isn't quite ordinary<br />

herself can only love a man who is fighting for<br />

something beyond the ordinary life' (pp.74-5).<br />

This makes Kate seem much more like Ramon than Cipriano. Firstly<br />

because Ramon wants to change Mexico, he is a fighter, as Kate<br />

says. Secondly because Cipriano is only a shadow of Ramon. He<br />

takes no attitude apart from those Ramon demands of him.<br />

Furthermore, Joachim was an Irish leader who fought to free<br />

Ireland from British dominion and Cipriano belongs to the<br />

Mexican army, he is a general and he is transforming nothing. He<br />

is a mere soldier in the lowest sense. He is no fighter. Only<br />

Ramon seems able to give Kate what she wants:<br />

... she knew that what she wanted was for her<br />

soul to live. The life of days and facts and

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!