29.12.2013 Views

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

stories show his internal conflict in terms of the fierce battle<br />

between his<br />

feelings.<br />

conscious intention and his unconscious<br />

Feelings always contradict the author's intention.<br />

This is perhaps a clear sign of the author's artistic honesty and<br />

because of this the conflict of the characters is never fully<br />

solved.<br />

And although the author sometimes tries to press his<br />

thumb in the scale to favor his intentions, he does not achieve<br />

it because his feelings are stronger and, therefore, there is<br />

always ambiguity in the way he finishes his stories.<br />

As for the theme of 'star-polarity' or balance in the whole<br />

opus of the author, I believe that it does not exist.<br />

It is more<br />

a question of who in the relation has sufficient strength to<br />

fight off the partner who wants to dominate.<br />

The so-called union<br />

of body and soul could not be reconciled or united by Lawrence.<br />

He simply could not do it in any of his stories.<br />

Here, I repeat,<br />

perhaps.the most 'balanced' relation seems to be Birkin and<br />

Ursula's, but we know that Birkin is a chauvinist and Ursula may<br />

succumb at his feet, although she protests against this side of<br />

her lover's theory.<br />

In the whole opus there is not really a<br />

balanced 'marriage' between the two halves of the self.<br />

Daleski<br />

and Sagar, for instance, think that in The Rainbow and Women in<br />

Love, specifically, there is a successful presentation of<br />

balance between the couples. But there is not. Balance between<br />

the characters implies balance between conflicting impulses<br />

(male vs female, body vs soul) in the author. This is not really<br />

reconciled.<br />

In the novels of the leadership phase, the search<br />

for balance is replaced by the search for power, for dominance.<br />

It may be useful here to quote from Mark Schorer's essay "On<br />

3<br />

Lady Chatterley's Lover" where Schorer discusses the distinction<br />

3 Modern British Fiction (New York, 1961).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!