29.12.2013 Views

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

37-2-<br />

don't'".<br />

Her reply to this does not indicate her own wish to<br />

decide, on the contrary, she keeps expecting the men to answer<br />

for her.<br />

Then her husband interferes in his hot, sensual,<br />

mesmeric voice: "'Yes, I want you! — Verdad! Verdad!' exclaimed<br />

Cipriano, in his low, secret, almost muttering voice" (ibid).<br />

Cipriano here plays a stupid clown because he takes Kate's<br />

questions and answers them only with the hot language of a<br />

passionate lover, blind to any other language than the one of<br />

the body.<br />

Kate says nothing to him because she in fact wants the<br />

answer to come from Ramon, not from Cipriano.<br />

Instead, she<br />

thinks (or Lawrence thinks for her):<br />

What a fraud I am! I know all the time it is I who<br />

don't altogether want them. I want myself to myself.<br />

But I can fool them so they shan't find out.<br />

For she heard the hot, phallic passion in<br />

Cipriano's voice (ibid).<br />

Notice the inversion of the statement 'For she heard the hot,<br />

phallic passion in Cipriano's voice1 which should actually come<br />

before Kate's thought.<br />

This certainly implies that Kate in fact<br />

does not care for her husband.<br />

Is Lawrence teasing the readers<br />

with this game of words? It seems that Ramon has guessed that<br />

Kate wants the decision to come from his mouth, for he leaves it<br />

clear that it is Kate Who must decide what she wants to do:<br />

"'You needn't commit yourself to us. Listen to your own best<br />

desire'".<br />

Kate's subsequent speech is only a challenge to<br />

Ramon: "'And if it tells me to go away?' she flashed defiant...".<br />

He does not answer but again returns to her her own decision:<br />

"'Then go! Oh, certainly go!'". Kate's response to this seems<br />

another trick (or perhaps she has become a puppet in Lawrence's<br />

hand): she starts crying! This implies her doubtful position:<br />

she has decided by herself and with Ramon's agreement.<br />

He has<br />

not committed himself in the decision.<br />

The fact that Kate has

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!