A critical analysis of the Modernists and the Hadeeth ... - Islam House

Wathiq too was instigated by Ibn Abu Dawood and his evil
companions to coerce the people into accepting the Qur'aan as a
creation. Wathiq however did not find it in his interest to imprison
Imam Ahmad. So he ordered Imam Ahmad to leave. Imam Ahmad
thus sought refuge away from public view for five years. Towards the
end of his caliphate, Allah guided Wathiq to retreat from his deviation
due of an interesting incident. People were being brought before
Wathiq in shackles and were being forced to accept that the Qur'aan is
a creation. Anyone who resisted was killed.
A man amongst them greeted Wathiq, "As-Salaam alaikum, O
Ameerul-Mu'mineen,"
to which Wathiq retorted, "Neither has Allah saved you, nor there
be any salaam (safety) on you."
The man said, "Verily, he who has nurtured you did not do it well."
He was referring to Wathiq's mentor Ibn Abu Dawood who was
also present there. The man recited the verse, "When you are
greeted with a greeting, greet in return with what is better than it
or (at least) return it equally." [Soorah an-Nisa (4): 86] and then said,
"You have not replied me with the same or the better."
The caliph was astonished and ordered Ibn Abu Dawood to debate
with him.
Ibn Abu Dawood asked him, "What do you say about the
Qur'aan?"
The man said, "You have not done justice to
me, I should initiate."
The caliph agreed and the man asked,
"What do you say about the Qur'aan? O
Ibn Abu Dawood."
He replied, "I say that the Qur'aan is
- 25 -