06.02.2013 Views

Primary Retinal Detachment

Primary Retinal Detachment

Primary Retinal Detachment

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Conclusion 169<br />

vitrectomy and search for the retinal break at the operating table,<br />

where the wage rate is 37% higher (Medicare fees from New York,<br />

New Jersey, Connecticut). If one does not find the break, a surgeon<br />

might be inclined to do a peripheral laser barricade augmented<br />

by an encircling band. The barrier operation, which was disappearing<br />

near the end of the twentieth century, is returning as a<br />

prophylactic supplement to primary vitrectomy and pneumatic<br />

retinopexy [54].<br />

Peer Review<br />

A third factor operating against the buckle operation for primary<br />

detachment, beyond the lack of training and the limit of reimbursement<br />

for the time spent, is the absence of peer review. Preoperative<br />

surgical rounds, where the surgical plan for retinal detachment<br />

was open for review, suggestion, criticism, and even censure,<br />

have disappeared; with 1-day surgery, there is not time for it. The<br />

surgeon admits his patient on the day of the operation with as<br />

much preparation as his schedule allowed, and, when the patient<br />

leaves the hospital later in the day with the eye filled with gas, there<br />

is no opportunity to evaluate the effort by his or her peers.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The proponents of primary vitrectomy claim that the final attachment<br />

rate after multiple procedures is 99%. In the series that we<br />

examined, it was 97%, equal to that of buckling. This is reassuring.<br />

They dismiss the morbidity of multiple operations and regard the<br />

frequent provocation of cataract as acceptable.<br />

We do not think it is possible to counteract the change in the<br />

treatment of retinal detachment. Perhaps market forces will relax,<br />

and peer review will return, or maybe new and less morbid methods<br />

to attach the retina will be invented. Admittedly, the incidence of

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!