13.07.2015 Views

Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport - Rdes.it

Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport - Rdes.it

Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport - Rdes.it

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

214 Giurisprudenza Internazionaleof a TUE provid<strong>ed</strong> by art. 4.4 of the WADC applies in a much earlier stagewhere the s<strong>it</strong>uation has not necessarily amount<strong>ed</strong> to an anti-doping ruleviolation. Furthermore, the absence of a right of WADA to review the grantor denial of a TUE makes <strong>it</strong> impossible for the WADA to determine whetherthe International F<strong>ed</strong>erations and anti-doping organizations apply the samestandards when they grant or deny TUEs. In the Panel’s opinion, this isamaterial <strong>di</strong>fference between the WADC and the FIFA DC. The Panel notes,however, that the TUE does not belong to the mandatory provisions of theWADC 23 .3.6 Testing (Article 5 WADC. Article IV FIFA RDC) 2447 Art. 5 of the WADC requires an IF to establish a register<strong>ed</strong> testingpool for international-level athletes. FIFA conducts in-compet<strong>it</strong>ion and outof-compet<strong>it</strong>iondoping tests only at matches and compet<strong>it</strong>ions organiz<strong>ed</strong> byFIFA. FIFA does not provide testing beyond. 25 The FIFA testing proc<strong>ed</strong>uresas set out in great detail in art. IV FIFA RDC are not substantially <strong>di</strong>fferentfrom the proc<strong>ed</strong>ures provid<strong>ed</strong> by art. 5 WADC and the highly detail<strong>ed</strong> WADAInternational Standard for Testing.3.7 Analysis of Samples and Results Management (Articles 6 and 7WADC. Article IV.6 FIFA RDC and Articles 133-138 FIFA DC) 2648 Accor<strong>di</strong>ng to art. IV.6.1 FIFA RDC, the analysis of the samples shallbe carri<strong>ed</strong> out in a laboratory accre<strong>di</strong>t<strong>ed</strong> by WADA. Such laboratories aresubject to the respective International Standards as issu<strong>ed</strong> by WADA 27 . Thissafeguards a uniform sample analysis under both the WADC and the FIFAAnti-Doping Rules.49 Art. 7.5 WADC allows for provisional suspensions, i.e. to impose asuspension prior to the final hearing. The opportun<strong>it</strong>y for a provisional hearingmust be given to the offender e<strong>it</strong>her before impos<strong>it</strong>ion of the provisionalsuspension or timely thereafter.50 Art. 133-138 FIFA DC provide that the chairman of the ju<strong>di</strong>cial bodymay pronounce provisional measures, inclu<strong>di</strong>ng provisional suspensions. Heis not oblig<strong>ed</strong> to hear the parties; he shall take his decisions bas<strong>ed</strong> on the____________________23Cf. para. 10.24Art. 5 WADC does not belong to the provisions which the WADC designates as “articles […]which must be incorporat<strong>ed</strong> into the rules of each Anti-Doping Organization w<strong>it</strong>hout anysubstantive changes.”25Testing beyond matches and compet<strong>it</strong>ions of FIFA is regulat<strong>ed</strong> by the national football f<strong>ed</strong>erationand/or the national Anti-Doping Organisations.26Art. 6 and 7 WADC do not belong to the provisions which the WADC designates as “articles[…] which must be incorporat<strong>ed</strong> into the rules of each Anti-Doping Organization w<strong>it</strong>hout anysubstantive changes.”27Art. 6.4 WADC.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!