Khawaja Zaheer Ahmed - PDMA

late in various phases, both due to incompetence and widespread corrupt
practices that continue to be seen in the disbursements of ex-gratia assistance or
rehabilitation. A former Prime Minister also joined the affectee-protestors.
14. As regards the specific grievances of the petitioners, the media
representatives and members of civil society who deposed before the
Commission at Islamabad and the affectees who met with the Commission
during field visits, their submissions are summarized below:-
a. Ms. Marvi Memon, MNA (the Petitioner in Constitution Petition
No.62 of 2010) from Thatta, in Sindh levelled serious allegations
based on a detailed account of her meticulously documented field
visits along the flood-route of River Indus that began from Gilgit-
Baltistan. Her contentions were supplemented by multi-media
presentations, video-clips and summary of day-to-day media
coverage of reported events to flag various aspects of
mismanagement and neglect in handling of the disaster, in all its
phases. According to the petitioner, relevant departments had failed
to faithfully undertake or execute pre-flood plans, upkeep the
maintenance works due to negligence, incompetence, corrupt
practices or combination thereof. It was asserted that specific
warnings by the Flood Commission and Meteorological Department
about high floods at Guddu and Sukkur barrages were ignored.
During rescue, Shikarpur flood affectees were denied access to
Benazirabad (formerly Nawabshah) and many others from upper
Sindh were not allowed relocation in Karachi. Breaching of Tori and
PB Bunds and B.S. Feeder and many more cuts/breaches violated
past practices and departmental procedures enforced in 1976 when
Ali-Wahn Bund was breached to save people and crops but that
was not allowed in the 2010 Flood. Drawing attention to her
frequent field-visits to affected areas, particularly in K.N. Shah and
Thatta in Sindh, she noted that most people alleged that their
Page 30 of 211