02.01.2014 Views

Yellowstone's Northern Range - Greater Yellowstone Science ...

Yellowstone's Northern Range - Greater Yellowstone Science ...

Yellowstone's Northern Range - Greater Yellowstone Science ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

lJO<br />

Year<br />

Estimate<br />

Comment<br />

Source<br />

1913 32,967<br />

1914 35,209<br />

1915 27,800<br />

37,192<br />

1916 11,515-11,564<br />

1917 10,769-17,422<br />

1918 20,700<br />

1919 18,694<br />

1920 No census<br />

"A census of elk in and along the north line of the park was taken<br />

between April 9 and May I...The elk were in excellent condition all<br />

winter, and but few dead ones were found ... "<br />

"A census was made again of the elk, comprising the northern herd in<br />

the park, between April 11 and May 2 ... "<br />

Quoting Supt. YNP for winter herd in Lamar and <strong>Yellowstone</strong> River<br />

Valleys. "At best these estimates are inaccurate and in many cases it<br />

is impossible to tell just how many belong to onc herd or if the<br />

animals are included in estimates of different herds,"<br />

Estimated total. "The weather was so mild and there was so little<br />

snow in March and April that the elk went up to higher ground<br />

earlier than usual, and it was impractical to take an accurate census of<br />

them."<br />

The former reported as a count including elk in the Madison,<br />

Gallatin, and <strong>Yellowstone</strong> River valleys; the latter was an estimate for<br />

the total herd. Additional reports of censuses exist in 1916 and<br />

contribute to controversy discussed in depth by Houston.<br />

The former reported as a census occurring between May 26 and June<br />

9; the latter estimate comes from adding nearly 7,000 elk not seen.<br />

"The northern group comprises slightly more than 19,000, the number<br />

having been determined by actual count conducted in the spring of<br />

1917 ..."<br />

"Game animals were reported during the month [of January] as<br />

follows" (Numbers approximate) ... "<br />

"In connection with their patrols, the rangers in the most important<br />

districts during March made a count of the elk. The total...not<br />

including those in GaUatin and Riverside districts nor those now<br />

ranging outside of the park, amounted to 18,694."<br />

Houston discusses in detail "the epitome of confusion [that] occurred<br />

during the winter of 1919-1920", which resulted in many "patently<br />

incorrect" reports of a disastrous winter and population crash.<br />

Supt. Brett<br />

Supt. Brett<br />

Simpson and Bailey,<br />

U.S. Forest Service<br />

and U.S. Biological<br />

Survey<br />

Supt. Brett<br />

Bailey, and U.S.<br />

Forest Service and<br />

U.S. Biological<br />

Surv. unpubl. rept.<br />

Supt. Lindsley and<br />

Gallatin NF Supv.<br />

Nelson rept.<br />

Graves and Nelson<br />

Supt. Lindsley<br />

Acting Supt. Hill<br />

Numerous, cited in<br />

Houston

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!