Sin death and beyond
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
SIN, DEATH AND BEYOND: M.M.NINAN<br />
WHO OR WHAT REINCARNATES IN HINDUISM?<br />
(REINCARNATION Its meaning <strong>and</strong> consequences by Ernest Vale)<br />
"According to the Upanishads <strong>and</strong> Vedanta philosophy, the entity that reincarnates is the<br />
impersonal self (atman). Atman does not have a personal nature, <strong>and</strong> so the use of the<br />
reflexive pronoun "self" is not suitable. Atman can be defined only through negating any<br />
personal attributes. Although it constitutes the existential substrata of human<br />
existence, atman cannot be the carrier of one’s "spiritual progress," because it cannot record<br />
any data produced in the illusory domain of psycho-mental existence. The spiritual progress<br />
one accumulates toward realizing the atman-Brahman identity is recorded by karma, or rather<br />
by a minimal amount of karmic debt. The whole physical <strong>and</strong> mental complex a human being<br />
consists of is reconstructed at (re)birth according to one’s karma. At this level, the newly<br />
shaped person experiences the fruits of "his" or "her" actions from previous lives <strong>and</strong> has to do<br />
his best to stop the vicious cycle avidya-karma-samsara.<br />
As a necessary aid in explaining the reincarnation mechanism, Vedanta adopted the concept<br />
of a subtle body (sukshma-sharira) which is attached to atman as long as its bondage lasts.<br />
This is the actual carrier of karmic debts. However, this "subtle body" cannot be a form of<br />
preserving one’s personal attributes, i.e., of any element of one's present conscious psychomental<br />
life. The facts recorded by the subtle body are a sum of hidden tendencies or<br />
impressions (samskara) imprinted by karma as seeds that will generate future behavior <strong>and</strong><br />
personal character. They will materialize unconsciously in the life of the individual, without<br />
giving one any hint at underst<strong>and</strong>ing his or her actual condition. There can be no form of<br />
transmitting conscious memory from one life to another, since it belongs to the world of illusion<br />
<strong>and</strong> dissolves at <strong>death</strong>."<br />
141