13.11.2016 Views

BEYOND SYRIA IRAQ

gDYvGxb

gDYvGxb

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

PUBLIC POLLING<br />

capita FTF ratio of any Arab country. But this does not necessarily mean<br />

Tunisia has the highest overall proportion of IS sympathizers in its total population.<br />

On the contrary; it may even mean that proportionally more Tunisians<br />

go off on jihad abroad precisely because they feel unwelcome in their<br />

own country. The fact is that, as with many other related questions, we just<br />

don’t know the answer to this conundrum.<br />

What general conclusions can we draw from this overview? First, of<br />

course, much more research is required. Second, one big thing we should<br />

already understand, but too often don’t, is that IS has precious little popular<br />

support in any Arab society polled and probably only a little more among<br />

the non-Arab Muslim majority worldwide or Muslim minority communities<br />

in the West. Third, this means two important, contrarian, and encouraging<br />

other things: the Islamic State is not in any position to capture new territory<br />

by winning hearts and minds. Nor is it likely to incite or inspire mass violence<br />

anywhere.<br />

And where IS does rule today, either in its core or remote provinces, that<br />

almost certainly does not reflect legitimacy or public support. Rather, its control<br />

comes from either pure coercion or passive acquiescence, in the absence<br />

of any practical alternative options for the local population. We should not<br />

expect any popular uprisings against existing IS domination. At the same<br />

time, we should not fear a popular push to put IS in power anywhere—or a<br />

major popular backlash against our continuing efforts to uproot it.<br />

65

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!