The Intelligent Troglodyte’s Guide to Plato’s Republic, 2016a

Back
Consider school sports teams. We still have men’s basketball and women’s
basketball, men’s soccer and women’s soccer, men’s volleyball and
women’s volleyball, and so on. Women rarely get to wrestle, and almost
never get to play football. Can this be justified rationally? It might be said
that women are on average weaker than men. But, Socrates would say, so
what? The strength of the average man or woman is irrelevant. What
matters is even matching. A tall brawny woman is likely to be a better
basketball player than a short flabby man. The idea wouldn’t necessarily be
to have the best women players play with the best men players. The idea
would be for the best players to play together, the mediocre players to play
together, and the poor players to play together. If all the players on a given
team were women, or were white, or what have you, it wouldn’t matter. The
point would be even matching, not forced integration. Is there a good reason
not to continue the sexual revolution and achieve equal treatment in school
sports?