BIOENERGY FOR EUROPE: WHICH ONES FIT BEST?
BIOENERGY FOR EUROPE: WHICH ONES FIT BEST?
BIOENERGY FOR EUROPE: WHICH ONES FIT BEST?
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
7.1 Country specific life cycle comparisons 127<br />
Miscanthus versus light oil / natural gas for district heat production – Germany<br />
Use of fossil fuels<br />
Greenhouse effect<br />
Acidification<br />
Eutrophication<br />
Summer smog<br />
Nitrous oxide**<br />
Human toxicity**<br />
* How to interpret the diagram<br />
Advantages for<br />
biofuel<br />
Advantages for<br />
fossil fuel<br />
Light oil<br />
Natural gas<br />
-1000 0 1000 2000<br />
German inhabitant equivalents* per 100 TJ<br />
The figure shows the results of comparisons between complete life cycles where light oil and natural<br />
gas respectively are substituted by Miscanthus for heat production. The unit refers to an amount of 100<br />
TJ of heat. This is equivalent to the average heat requirement of about 25,000 inhabitants of Germany in<br />
one year or a Miscanthus production of about 450 ha/a. In this case for example the amount of fossil<br />
fuel saved if light oil is substituted by Miscanthus is equal to the amount which nearly 700 German<br />
citizens would on average consume in one year (this is what is meant by “German inhabitant equivalents”).<br />
Remarks and conclusions<br />
The results show that both Miscanthus as well as light oil and natural gas have certain ecological advantages<br />
and disadvantages.<br />
• Advantages of the biofuel: use of fossil fuels, greenhouse effect, compared to natural gas also summer<br />
smog (small)<br />
• Advantages of the fossil fuel: acidification, eutrophication, compared to light oil also summer smog<br />
(small)<br />
• Low or no significance: –<br />
The data for ozone depletion and human toxicity tend to have a high uncertainty. Therefore these categories<br />
should not be included in the final assessment. (**See Chapter 4.1.2 and for details on all impact<br />
categories 3.3 and 3.4.)<br />
A further assessment in favour of or against Miscanthus or light oil / natural gas cannot be carried<br />
out on a scientific basis, because for this purpose subjective value judgements regarding the individual<br />
environmental categories are required which differ from person to person.