BIOENERGY FOR EUROPE: WHICH ONES FIT BEST?
174 7 Annex CTI CTI – Thermotechnical Italian Committee, Headquarters: via Pascoli, 41, I-20129 Milano Phone: 0039 02 236-7330 FAX: 0039 02 236-3927 Personnel Extension e-mail Prof. Giovanni Riva Dr. Elio Smedile Dr. Antonio Panvini riva@clausius.energ.polimi.it esmedile@tin.it panvini@cti2000.it FAL FAL – Eidgenössische Forschungsanstalt für Agrarökologie und Landbau, Reckenholzstr. 191, CH- 8046 Zürich Phone: 0041 1 377 73 50 FAX: 0041 1 377 72 01 Personnel Extension e-mail Dr. Gérard Gaillard gerard.gaillard@fal.admin.ch FAT FAT – Eidgenössische Forschungsanstalt für Agrarwirtschaft und Landtechnik (Swiss Federal Research Station for Agricultural Economics and Engineering), CH-8356 Tänikon Phone: 0041 52 368-3332 FAX: 0041 52 365-1190 Personnel Extension e-mail Lena Heinzer -3344 lena.heinzer@fat.admin.ch IFEU IFEU – Institut für Energie- und Umweltforschung Heidelberg (Institute for Energy and Environmental Research), Wilckensstraße 3, D-69120 Heidelberg Phone: 0049 6221 4767-0 FAX: 0049 6221 4767-19 Personnel Extension e-mail Dr. Guido Reinhardt Dr. Andreas Patyk Nicolai Jungk MSc -31 -38 -60 guido.reinhardt@ifeu.de andreas.patyk@ifeu.de nicolai.jungk@fb4.ifeu.de INRA INRA – Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, unité «Environnement et Grandes Cultures» F-78850 Thiverval-Grignon Phone: 0033 1 3081-5555 FAX: 0033 1 3081-5563 Personnel Extension e-mail Dr. Ghislain Gosse Dr. Bruno Leviel -5524 -5586 ghislain.gosse@bcgn.grignon.inra.fr bruno.leviel@bcgn.grignon.inra.fr TUD TUD – Technical University of Denmark, Institute for Manufacturing Engineering, Department of Process and Production Engineering, Building 424, DK-2800 Lyngby Phone: 0045 4593 6100 FAX: 0045 4593 5556 Personnel Extension e-mail Dr. Bo Pedersen Weidema Anne Merete Nielsen Dr. Per H. Nielsen Dr. Nina Caspersen 0045-45254800 bow@lca.dk amn@ipt.dtu.dk nielsen@ait.ac.th nc@ipt.dtu.dk
7.5 Data availability 175 7.5 Data availability The following documents can be found on a CD-ROM available from the IFEU-Institute, Heidelberg, Germany (see address below), or from the following Internet site: Data set Content www.ifeu.de/nr_fair.htm life-cycle-charts.ppt flow charts of the life cycles under study external-annex.doc external annex to the final report: Goals of the study Functions of the product systems Functional unit Allocation procedures System expansion for protein fodder by-products Choice of reference-systems and technologies Characterisation of resource uses and environmental impacts Methodology for ‘Land Use’ Data collection guidelines Flow for the data collection Results ‘Land Use and Biodiversity’ Methodology for ‘Socio-economic and political analyses’ lca-1-triticale.xls life cycle assessment of triticale versus hard coal for power production lca-2-rme.xls life cycle assessment of RME versus diesel fuel for transportation lca-3-sme.xls life cycle assessment of SME versus diesel fuel for transportation lca-4-etbe.xls life cycle assessment of ETBE versus MTBE for transportation lca-5-misc.xls life cycle assessment of Miscanthus versus light oil and natural gas for district heat production lca-6-willow.xls life cycle assessment of willow versus light oil and natural gas for district heat production lca-7-wood.xls life cycle assessment of traditional fire wood versus light oil and natural gas for residential heat production lca-8-biogas.xls life cycle assessment of biogas versus natural gas for combined heat and power production lca-9-straw.xls life cycle assessment of wheat straw versus light oil and natural gas for district heat production all-chains.xls LCA results of all national and European chains If problems should arise with the downloading of these files please consult: Dr. A. Patyk IFEU-Institut für Energie- und Umweltforschung Heidelberg GmbH (Institute for Energy and Environmental Research Heidelberg) Wilckensstrasse 3, D - 69120 Heidelberg, Germany Tel: +49-6221-4767-38, Fax -19 E-Mail: andreas.patyk@ifeu.de
BIOENERGY FOR EUROPE: WHICH ONES FI
Contents Executive summary.........
Contents III 5.3.2 Variation in col
2 Executive summary Table 1 Investi
4 Executive summary Result of the c
6 Executive summary Economic aspect
1 Goals, target groups and general
1 Goals, target groups and general
14 2 Biofuels under study The resul
16 2 Biofuels under study 2.3 Life
18 2 Biofuels under study 2.3.3 Mis
20 2 Biofuels under study 2.4.2 Sun
22 2 Biofuels under study 2.5 Life
24 2 Biofuels under study 2.5.3 Bio
3 Life cycle assessment of biofuels
3.2 Scope definition of the investi
3.2 Scope definition of the investi
3.2 Scope definition of the investi
3.3 Inventory analysis 35 then. Eve
3.3 Inventory analysis 37 using the
3.4 Impact assessment 39 energy cro
3.4 Impact assessment 41 The IPCC p
3.5 Interpretation 43 of the indivi
3.5 Interpretation 45 Fossil fuel p
4 Environmental results: presentati
4.1 Introduction 49 case excluding
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.2 European results: biofuels comp
4.3 European results: biofuels for
4.3 European results: biofuels for
4.3 European results: biofuels for
4.4 Summary of country specific res
4.4 Summary of country specific res
4.4 Summary of country specific res
4.4 Summary of country specific res
4.5 Summary of comparisons between
80 5 Socio-economic and political a
82 5 Socio-economic and political a
84 5 Socio-economic and political a
86 5 Socio-economic and political a
88 5 Socio-economic and political a
90 6 Conclusions and recommendation
92 6 Conclusions and recommendation
94 6 Conclusions and recommendation
7 Annex 7.1 Country specific life c
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com
7.1 Country specific life cycle com