MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALIZATION OF ART, MEDIA AND PERFORMANCE 107A Lighthearted CharacteristicBeside those visual styles I found in manga, there is alsoan interesting assertion from Taiyo Matsumoto, ayoung manga artist known for his much-praisedTekkin Konkurito (Black & White) and Go GoMonster.In his youth, Taiyo traveled to Paris and America, insearch of the essence of style in European andAmerican comics. He found that European comicstend to be intellectual, while American comics tend tobe cool. And he concluded that Japanese comics tend tobe lighthearted.When I looked closely at my manga collection, I feltthat the “lighthearted” traits Taiyo perceived appliednot just to the way the stories developed but to thevisual nature of the story telling too.The visuals of manga, with all their over-the-tophumorous takes on everything, felt like a feast of mortalmoments, a jubilation in everything that is ephemeral.No logic, no burden of meanings, no biblical scale ofbattles between good and evil, just laughter, games,poses, cute things, and the joy of an imagination inwhich anything goes. The seriousness in manga is oftenvery playful. There is always a detached view of theworld lurking behind most of the high drama in mangastories.Thailand: an affirmation of dominationAnd then, I went to Thailand. First, to Bangkok for afew days; and then to Chiang Mai for another two andhalf months of research. After the cold climate and thestress from the Great Tohoku Earthquake of 11 March2011, the dust and the heat in Chiang Mai felt like afirst step in my eventual destination, the equally dustyand hot Jakarta.“In Thailand, there is no such thing as comics”, saidPooh, in the library of the Jim Thompson Art Center,one rainy afternoon. “We don’t usually use the term“comics”. We use the term ‘cartoon’, and it is used forcomics, cartoons, drawings for cover art, andanimation”.It is true. My dear friend in Chiang Mai, Jay Santiphap,a documentary filmmaker who I met in Yokohamaduring his artist residency program in 2010, once gaveme three books with cartoon covers, and saidenthusiastically, “I want to show you a legendary Thaicartoonist! He was very popular when I was a kid!”When I opened the books, they weren’t comic booksor cartoons at all. They were storybooks for children,with cartoon illustrations here and there.But there is now a whole lot of manga everywhere.They are translated into the Thai language, whosescript is more similar to Javanese than Japanese script.Along Suthep Road near my apartment in ChiangMai, I found at least 10 comic rental shops with mostof their books being manga.Are there no Thai comics? Of course there are someThai comics. Actually, the history of popular Thaicomics began as early as the Siamese Revolution of1932. After the revolution, Thailand had manypopular comics such as Sang Thong and Khun Mauncomics, which adapted the Popeye and Mickey Mousecomics for local readers. In 1952, Thailand’s firstindigenous comic book series for children wasintroduced: Tuk Ka Ta, written by Pimol Kalasee.Traditionally, ghost stories and humorous comics arethe main genres produced in Thailand.But there was no advance consumption-economy inThailand. There is no industrial approach attached toThailand’s own comics, unlike the brutally effectiveapproach in Japan.Pooh said that this was because Thailand’s popularculture has no roots, but I still think it’s an economicthing. A case in point, Pooh also thinks that Americanpopular culture has no roots, and look at how bigpopular culture industry is in America. (Of course, Idon’t share her opinion about the rootedness ofAmerican popular culture either.)And so, economically speaking, Thai comics arevulnerable from the surge of cultural product frommore developed countries such as America and Japan.In manga’s case, the penetration of the Thai marketbegan in the late 1970s or early 1980s. “I have readmanga and watched anime since I can remember”, saidJay Santiphap, who is in his late thirties.Fusanosuke Natsume, in his research on mangainfluence in Thailand and Indonesia under the APIfellowship program, divided Thai comics into twomain categories. First, the traditional Thai comics, soldon newsstands at very cheap prices (five baht). Second,comics of Japanese origin, targeted at children of thenew middle class. And now, there is a new trend ofThe Work of the 2010/2011 API Fellows
108 Panel 3Thai comics by local youth with the style of shojo andshonenmanga, supported by the same constituents asJapanese comics in Thailand, sold in bookstores with arather expensive price (around 50 baht).I found myself attracted to the cheap Thai comics. Theformat is very similar to Indonesian cheap comics thatusually contain religious and humorous themes. Theyare also very similar to the Red Comics Books thatbegan the manga industry in Japan.When I held those cheap Thai comics, I thought, hereit is, an affirmation of the domination of the mangaindustry: this cheap comic, with its cheap paper and poorprint quality, sold on the periphery of the market, outsidethe formal institution of the market (the immaculatelyshiny bookstores). Who knows what the future holds foryou, O marginalized one?And I still don’t have a clear understanding on whyOyas Sujiwo was compelled to spread a Japanese flagduring Indonesian Independence Day. I just know thathe doesn’t do that anymore.NOTES1234This paper is a first draft and is still in development.Nonetheless, I dedicate the paper to Rika Febriyani, withoutwhom my journey would not be possible. I am also grateful tomany others who have helped me, especially KrisnadiYuliawan, my chief editor in Rumahfilm.<strong>org</strong>, Rane Hafiedzin Tokyo, Ade Armando and Putut Widjanarko in Jakarta,and Jay Santhipap in Chiang Mai. And of course, to all thehelpful board members and staff of the Nippon Foundation,API Fellowship program.The popular Japanese term “otaku” has a slightly differentmeaning outside Japan then the original Japanese meaning. Iwill get back to this difference later, but for now, suffice to saythat the term is used by Daniel Choo for a group of peoplearound the world (usually youth) who are immersed inmanga and anime (Japanese animation) subculture.Millennium in Maps: Culture, a supplement for the GlobalCulture issue of National Geographic, vol. 196, no. 2, August1999.As promised to the API Fellowships Program in Jakarta, I amwriting a journalistic book about the globalization of mangasubculture and visual identity. This work is still in process.But as it turned out, my stay in Japan was very inspiring and Ihave already completed a manuscript about my first monththere, titled Sebulan di Negeri Manga (A Month in MangaCountry). The manuscript is now on the process of beingpublished in Jakarta.56Roland Barthes, Empire of Signs, translated by RichardHoward. 1982. Hill and Wang, New York.Kawai is a contemporary Japanese word, usually translated as“cute”. It has becomes a subculture in itself, the Japaneseaffinity and excitement for all things cute, known as “Kawaiculture”.7 Mary Grigsby, “‘Sailormoon’: ‘Manga (Comics)’ and ‘Anime(Cartoon)’ Superheroine Meets Barbie: GlobalEntertainment Commodity Comes to the United States,”Journal of Popular Culture 32 (1998): 65, quoted by WendySiuyi Wong, “Globalizing Manga: From Japan to Hong Kongand Beyond,” Mechademia Volume 1, University ofMinnesota Press, 2006.8Donald Richie, The Image Factory: Fads & Fashions inJapan. 2003. Reaktion Books, London.9 Donald Richie, idem.10 One could dispute this assertion quite easily. What aboutHollywood? Yes, for a long time, the USA could claimsupremacy in the world’s “image-based industries”. Butdespite its size in the world, the American image-basedindustry is much smaller than its military industry. In Japan,the motor industry is the country’s largest, and one couldargue that it is partly a life-style based industry and partly animage-related industry.11 Many equate the Meiji Restoration with the opening up ofJapan to foreign (Western) influence after long isolation.Actually, the first time Japan opened its doors to Westerninfluence was in 1854, with the treaty of amity with theUnited States, and continuing in 1858 with commercialtreaties signed with the US, The Netherlands, Russia,England, and France. But the treaties did not place Japan onan equal footing. The Western countries considered Japan asan underdeveloped country. The Japanese gradually realizedthat they were not equals to the Westerners, so they sped upmodernization so they could demand a more equal position.The Meiji Restoration itself was a restructuring process of thegovernment system into a more modern (more centralized)system from the earlier feudalistic system.12 I found out about this after I asked around about what is sofascinating about Germany for a Japanese, so much so that wecan find many German references in the comics of OsamuTezuka and Naoki Urasawa?13 Wendy Siuyi Wong, idem.14 As defined by Hiroki Azuma, a self-proclaimed otaku whohappened to be a philosopher, otaku is: “…a general termreferring to those who indulge in forms of subculture stronglylinked to anime, video games, computers, science fiction,special-effects, anime figurines, and so on….”ept Thisdefinition can be found in his book, translated by Jonathan E.Abel and Shion Kono, Otaku, Japan’s Database Animals,University of Minnesota Press, 2009.15 A well-known, and much debated, definition of comics fromScott McCloud’s seminal work, Understanding Comics,1993. Tundra Publishing.The Work of the 2010/2011 API Fellows
- Page 2 and 3:
CULTURE, POWER AND PRACTICES:THE GL
- Page 7 and 8:
viABOUT THE BOOKCULTURE, POWER AND
- Page 9 and 10:
viiiACKNOWLEDGEMENTSThe API Coordin
- Page 11 and 12:
x(co-authored with Gunawan Wiradi,
- Page 13 and 14:
xiiSri Wahyuni is the director of t
- Page 15 and 16:
xivThe gap between rich and poor is
- Page 17 and 18:
xviand development mainly: Economy,
- Page 19 and 20:
xviiiIn closing, I would like to qu
- Page 21 and 22:
xxmovements to defend their rights,
- Page 23 and 24:
xxiicomplex relationships between f
- Page 25 and 26:
xxivIndonesian Academy of Social Sc
- Page 28 and 29:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 30 and 31:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 32 and 33:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 34 and 35:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 36 and 37:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 38 and 39:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 40 and 41:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 42 and 43:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 44 and 45:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 46 and 47:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 48 and 49:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 50 and 51:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 52 and 53:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 54 and 55:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 56 and 57:
MULTIPLE MODERNITIES: GLOBALIZATION
- Page 58 and 59:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 60 and 61:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 62 and 63:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 64 and 65:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 66 and 67:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 68 and 69:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 70 and 71:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 72 and 73:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 74 and 75:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 76 and 77:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 78 and 79:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 80 and 81:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 82:
POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 85 and 86: 58 Panel 2(Left) Kurazukuri are anc
- Page 88 and 89: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 90 and 91: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 92 and 93: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 94 and 95: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 96 and 97: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 98 and 99: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 100 and 101: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 102 and 103: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 104 and 105: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 106 and 107: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 108 and 109: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 110 and 111: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 112 and 113: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 114 and 115: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 116 and 117: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 118 and 119: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 120 and 121: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 122 and 123: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 124 and 125: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 126 and 127: POTENTIAL OF LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PR
- Page 128 and 129: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 130 and 131: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 132 and 133: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 136 and 137: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 138 and 139: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 140 and 141: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 142 and 143: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 144 and 145: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 146 and 147: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 148 and 149: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 150 and 151: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 152 and 153: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 154 and 155: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 156 and 157: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 158 and 159: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 160 and 161: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 162 and 163: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 164 and 165: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA THE GLOBALI
- Page 166 and 167: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 168 and 169: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 170 and 171: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 172 and 173: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 174 and 175: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 176 and 177: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 178 and 179: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 180 and 181: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 182 and 183: MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 184 and 185:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 186 and 187:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 188 and 189:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 190 and 191:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 192 and 193:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 194 and 195:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 196 and 197:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 198 and 199:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 200 and 201:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 202 and 203:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 204 and 205:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 206 and 207:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 208 and 209:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 210 and 211:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 212 and 213:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 214 and 215:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 216 and 217:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 218 and 219:
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES VIA SPIRITUALIT
- Page 220 and 221:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 222 and 223:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 224 and 225:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 226 and 227:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 228 and 229:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 230 and 231:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 232 and 233:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 234 and 235:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 236 and 237:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 238 and 239:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 240 and 241:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 242 and 243:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 244 and 245:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 246 and 247:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 248 and 249:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 250 and 251:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 252 and 253:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 254 and 255:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 256 and 257:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 258 and 259:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 260 and 261:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 262 and 263:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 264 and 265:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 266 and 267:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 268 and 269:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 270 and 271:
FLUX AND FLOWS OF PEOPLE, POWER AND
- Page 272 and 273:
OPENING REMARKS AND OVERVIEWDr. Rat
- Page 274 and 275:
247There is also a massive movement
- Page 276 and 277:
249need to be looked at, as globali
- Page 278 and 279:
251Appendix IWorkshop ScheduleThe T
- Page 280 and 281:
25313:00 - 15:00 Concluding PanelCh
- Page 282 and 283:
255THAILANDAroon Puritat, Artist an
- Page 284 and 285:
257RAPPORTEURSGarry MorrisonMarian
- Page 286 and 287:
Communication, Education and Public
- Page 288 and 289:
261have used tourism as a mechanism
- Page 290 and 291:
263Panel 4: Multiple Modernities vi
- Page 292 and 293:
265out how Asian women politicians
- Page 294 and 295:
267CONTACT DETAILS (as of March 201