27.12.2012 Views

Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library

Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library

Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

258 Chapter 20 · Minimal Residual Disease Studies in <strong>Acute</strong> Lymphoblastic Leukemia<br />

Table 20.5. MRD studies in Ph+ALL<br />

Study N Rx Relapsed MRD-status Major conclusion<br />

MRD+ MRD–<br />

Gehly 1991 [92] 4 Allo 1/1 (100%) 0/3 (0%) Interval between MRD detection and relapse<br />

in Ph+ALL may be relatively short and quite<br />

different from Ph+ CML post transplant<br />

2 Auto 1/1 (100%) 1/1 (100%)<br />

Miyamura 1992 9 Allo 5/5 (100%) 1/4 (25%) Median interval between PCR positivity and<br />

[91]<br />

clinical relapse was only 4 weeks<br />

6 Auto 2/2 (100%) 0/4 (0%)<br />

Radich 1995 [93] 8 Auto 1/8 (12%) – PCR+ following Allo-SCT predictive of relapse<br />

Mitterbauer 1995 7 – 6/6 (100%) 1/1 (100%) One-step combined with two-step RQ-PCR<br />

[88]<br />

analysis gives valuable information about the<br />

efficacy of treatment and the dynamics of the<br />

leukemia<br />

Radich 1997 [90] 30 Allo 8/21 (38%) 0/9 (0%) Median time from first PCR-positive test to<br />

relapse was 94 days<br />

6 Auto 2/2 (100%) 2/4 (50%) p190 confers higher risk of relapse than p210<br />

Sierra 1997 [89] 18 Allo 5/18 (62%) – PCR+ following match Allo-SCT correlates<br />

with relapse<br />

Preudhomme 1997 8 CT 6/7 (85%) 0/1 (0%) Relapse is always preceded by switch to PCR<br />

[87]<br />

positivity of Ph+ by 4 to 6 months<br />

5 Allo 3/3 (100%) 0/2 (0%) Lower sensitivity of RT-PCR in PB compared<br />

with BM<br />

4 Auto 2/3 (66%) 0/1 (0%)<br />

Mitterbauer 1999 4 CT 4/4 (100%) – Relapse is preceded by 5 to 15 weeks by one<br />

[74]<br />

step PCR<br />

3 Allo 2/3(66%) –<br />

2 Auto 0/2 (0%) –<br />

CT = Chemotherapy<br />

Auto = Autologous stem cells transplant<br />

Allo=Allogeneic stem cell transplant<br />

also has begun to provide important insights into the efficacy<br />

of treatment for specific molecular cytogenetic<br />

subsets of ALL.<br />

Several important issues remain to be answered in<br />

carefully controlled trials. If MRD measurements are<br />

to be incorporated into clinical trials and used for treatment<br />

stratification and evaluation of treatment efficacy,<br />

the unresolved issues of technique standardization and<br />

quality control must be addressed. The Europe Against<br />

Cancer (EAC) and BIOMED initiatives have resulted in<br />

the development of standardized and validated method-<br />

ology for quantitative PCR analysis in order to permit<br />

accurate comparison of MRD data [46]. Adoption of this<br />

approach in future trials and standardization of methodologies<br />

for flow cytometric MRD studies will be essential<br />

to accurately evaluate data from different clinical<br />

trials, and to help to answer important questions that<br />

remain including: (1) what level of MRD is clinically important;<br />

(2) when are the critical treatment time-points<br />

for MRD evaluation; (3) will MRD-based treatment intervention<br />

improve outcome. Finally, any MRD result<br />

must be interpreted in the context of the treatment ad-

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!