Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library
Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library
Acute Leukemias - Republican Scientific Medical Library
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
84 Chapter 5 · <strong>Acute</strong> Lymphoblastic Leukemia: Epidemiology and Etiology<br />
that showed evidence of statistically significant clustering<br />
of ALL in preschool children in small geographic regions<br />
(TPUs) in the highest decile of population growth<br />
during 1981–1991 [5]; a Canadian study in which leukemia<br />
incidence among children under 5 years of age was<br />
higher than expected in rural areas where the population<br />
grew, and lower than expected in growing urban<br />
areas [62]; and a US study using data from the SEER<br />
program that showed that rural counties with the greatest<br />
increase in population from 1980–1989 had the highest<br />
childhood leukemia incidence rates [153]. In contrast,<br />
in a study conducted in France, leukemia mortality<br />
rates were average among preschool children who<br />
resided in 43 rapidly-growing French administrative<br />
units (communes) [69].<br />
5.3.1.5 Prenatal Infection by a Specific<br />
Leukemogenic Pathogen<br />
According to Smith’s hypothesis [136, 137], high rates of<br />
ALL are attributable to in utero exposures to infections<br />
that result mainly in cases of precursor B-cell ALL. To<br />
investigate this hypothesis, several studies have compared<br />
ALL rates among children of mothers who<br />
reported infections during pregnancy to children of<br />
mothers who did not report infections during pregnancy.<br />
Early studies have been reviewed by Little [78]<br />
and show equivocal results. For example, the Oxford<br />
Survey of Childhood Cancers, a matched case-control<br />
study in England and Wales, found that children of<br />
mothers ill with an infective disease during pregnancy<br />
had increased rates of childhood malignancies (13 cases<br />
among mothers with infections during pregnancy versus<br />
1 case among control mothers) [144]. However, in<br />
a more recent and more focused matched case-control<br />
study in Scotland, infection (any, respiratory tract, viral,<br />
genitourinary, or fungal) during pregnancy did not statistically<br />
significantly affect the risk of ALL in children<br />
ages 0 to 14 [85]. Similarly, a study by Infante-Rivard et<br />
al. looking at recurrent maternal infections did not find<br />
a statistically significant association with ALL in children<br />
[47]. However, a study of maternal lower genital<br />
tract infection reported a statistically significant association<br />
[99], as did a study of mothers with Epstein-Barr<br />
virus (EBV) [72].<br />
5.3.1.6 Delayed Exposure to Pathogens<br />
in General<br />
Greaves’ hypothesis is that secondary mutations and/or<br />
proliferation due to early exposure to general infectious<br />
agents transmitted from parents, siblings, and other<br />
contacts early in life will tend to reduce the risk of childhood<br />
ALL. This is because he believes that ALL is a consequence<br />
of two independent mutations: the first occurring<br />
in utero or shortly after birth, and the second occurring<br />
between 2 and 6 years of age that may be triggered<br />
by infection [35, 38]. Supporting this theory is the<br />
observation that the majority of childhood ALL cases<br />
diagnosed between ages 2 and 6 have the TEL/AML1<br />
mutation. For example, in one study, eight of 12 children<br />
ages 2 to 5 recently diagnosed with TEL-AML1-positive<br />
ALL, including a pair of twins, were found to have<br />
TEL-AML1 fusion in the neonatal blood spots on their<br />
Guthrie cards, and the twins shared the same TEL-<br />
AML1 sequence (Wiemels et al. 1999 a). This is interpreted<br />
to be the first of the two mutations in Greaves’<br />
theory.<br />
His theory supposes that a second mutation occurs<br />
in early childhood, causing ALL. The second mutation<br />
may be promoted by common infections. Further, relative<br />
isolation, as in Kinlen’s hypothesis, may delay exposures<br />
to common infections, enabling the susceptible<br />
preleukemic cells to multiply, increases the likelihood<br />
of occurrence of the second mutation.<br />
Various sources of childhood infection, or protection<br />
from infection, have been considered in light of this<br />
hypothesis. Breast feeding, an opportunity for infectious<br />
exposure after birth, tends to show decreased risk<br />
of ALL, although this effect may be confounded by SES,<br />
according to McNally [88], as cases in these studies<br />
tended to have lower SES. As a counter example, researchers<br />
have shown that attendance at a day care facility<br />
increases a child’s risk of infection, and thus should<br />
increase their risk of ALL according to this theory, but<br />
was found to be protective. However, as with breast<br />
feeding, SES may be a confounder as cases tended to<br />
have lower SES. Other sources of infectious exposures,<br />
such as older siblings, parents with occupations that<br />
bring them into contact with many people, and migration,<br />
also tend to be protective [88]. Studies have also<br />
found associations of allergies and asthma with ALL<br />
[139, 154].<br />
Finally, seasonality may suggest an infectious etiology.<br />
Various authors have examined the seasonal pat-