SMS Siemag AG - Alu-web.de
SMS Siemag AG - Alu-web.de
SMS Siemag AG - Alu-web.de
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
technology<br />
A hot topic: Specifying linings for industrial kilns and furnaces<br />
Dave Barrington, general manager, Morgan Advanced Materials<br />
Selecting the most effective insulation<br />
material for furnace applications is a key<br />
consi<strong>de</strong>ration and one that can <strong>de</strong>liver<br />
a major performance advantage and<br />
measurable commercial return. When the<br />
impact of thermal conductivity on longterm<br />
cost and energy efficiency is taken<br />
into account, the benefits of an effective<br />
insulation material soon become apparent.<br />
A range of materials is available<br />
for the market, yet it can be difficult to<br />
un<strong>de</strong>rstand the benefits of one material<br />
when compared to another. However,<br />
whatever insulation material is chosen, its<br />
key attribute should be low thermal conductivity,<br />
which will enable it to restrict<br />
the flow of heat from the furnace to the<br />
external environment.<br />
Heat loss from a high temperature source such<br />
as a furnace is dominated by infra-red radiation.<br />
This is blocked by the fibres contained<br />
in a fibrous insulation material. The larger the<br />
number of fibres, the more effective the insulation<br />
will be. A superior insulation material will<br />
therefore have the best possible fibre in<strong>de</strong>x<br />
and contain a minimal number of ‘shot’ (unfiberised<br />
globular glass fibre) particles. Some<br />
materials on the market feature high shot<br />
content and coarse fibres, neither of which<br />
are beneficial for blocking high temperature<br />
thermal radiation.<br />
When specifying insulating materials for<br />
use as back-up lining in kilns and furnaces,<br />
which have castable or brick forming the hot<br />
face, <strong>de</strong>signers and specifiers must look beyond<br />
the initial purchase cost of the insulating<br />
materials to ensure their system will <strong>de</strong>liver<br />
optimum long-term performance and return<br />
on investment. The main options for these applications<br />
are typically calcium silicate or low<br />
biopersistent fibre-based boards. Calcium silicate<br />
has been commercially available for more<br />
than 50 years, its high compressive strength<br />
makes it well suited to kiln car bases.<br />
The compressive strength of calcium silicate<br />
might seem like a key benefit, and while it can<br />
endure heavy loads, its lack of flexibility does<br />
mean the material can be prone to cracking<br />
when put un<strong>de</strong>r certain strains that are difficult<br />
for the material to withstand. Fibrebased<br />
boards <strong>de</strong>rive their strength from the<br />
interlinking of fibres during manufacture. The<br />
more fibres that are available to link together,<br />
then the greater the strength and durability<br />
Calcium silicate edge<br />
of the board. The advantages to a board with<br />
high fibre count inclu<strong>de</strong> easy installation and<br />
handling, excellent strength and resistance to<br />
cracking.<br />
testing thermal conductivity<br />
Low biopersistent fibre-based boards were introduced<br />
to the market in the mid 1990s. The<br />
latest versions combine high-specification low<br />
biopersistent fibres, fillers and organic bin<strong>de</strong>rs.<br />
These boards are engineered to maximise<br />
the content of insulating low biopersistent fibres<br />
by reducing the size and amount of ‘shot’,<br />
and so <strong>de</strong>liver significantly reduced thermal<br />
conductivity offering enhanced energy-saving<br />
properties.<br />
Recent tests carried out at the most common<br />
operating temperatures for furnace backup<br />
board – between 600 and 800 ºC – revealed<br />
that in the key area of thermal conductivity,<br />
the latest low biopersistent fibre-based board<br />
outperformed calcium silicate by an average<br />
of 20 percent at 600 ºC and 15 percent at<br />
800 ºC. While calcium silicate typically costs<br />
less than low biopersistent fibre-based board,<br />
the wasted heat and associated energy costs<br />
more than outweigh the lower initial purchase<br />
cost.<br />
The physical properties of the two materials<br />
should also be evaluated by specifiers.<br />
Morgan Advanced Materials low biopersistent<br />
fibre-based Superwool Plus Blok <strong>de</strong>livers greater<br />
process advantages and more energy-efficient<br />
solutions in furnace applications<br />
Calcium silicate corner<br />
Calcium silicate is brittle, making it prone<br />
to chipping, crumbling and breakage during<br />
transportation, handling and stacking. These<br />
issues are ma<strong>de</strong> worse during machining and<br />
installation. Calcium silicate also creates consi<strong>de</strong>rably<br />
greater levels of dust than low biopersistent<br />
fibre-based board when chopped,<br />
shaped or handled, which potentially exposes<br />
operatives to the inhalation of a particulate.<br />
Dealing with this requires the use of appropriate<br />
respiratory protective equipment, which<br />
adds to the cost.<br />
the advantages to a<br />
water-resistant system<br />
A further key issue with these products is that<br />
of water absorption, as one installation option<br />
is to apply a castable material directly onto<br />
the back-up lining material. While low biopersistent<br />
fibre based board products are treated<br />
to be water repellent (hydrophobic), calcium<br />
silicate boards are highly water absorbent. This<br />
can result in the castable becoming dry and<br />
not curing correctly. It can also result in water<br />
becoming trapped in the back-up lining, leading<br />
to possible material damage. Therefore, in<br />
addition to accelerating heat loss and requiring<br />
more energy, the calcium silicate board<br />
will physically <strong>de</strong>teriorate and compromise<br />
the effectiveness of the system, resulting in a<br />
shorter product lifespan and potentially unsafe<br />
working conditions. Leading low biopersistent<br />
fibre-based boards do not require a<br />
water vapour barrier.<br />
the true cost of energy efficiency<br />
Demand for energy around the world is steadily<br />
increasing year-on-year, and looks set to<br />
continue to rise in years to come. There are<br />
numerous reasons for companies to prioritise<br />
the energy efficiency of their operations, including<br />
surcharges on energy bills, tax credits<br />
for energy-saving initiatives and increased<br />
© Margan Advanced Materials<br />
ALUMINIUM · 5/2013 53