31.10.2015 Views

ARCHITECTURE

artofinequality_150917_web

artofinequality_150917_web

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

this 10 percent is not necessarily the same 10 percent of<br />

wage earners represented by the tenants of New York by<br />

Gehry, since even in “very high inequality” of labor income,<br />

that 10 percent would command only 45 percent of<br />

the wages. The difference—between wealth due to capital<br />

and wealth due to wages—is what accounts for the much<br />

higher measure of “total inequality” projected by Piketty,<br />

in which 10 percent of the population accounts for a combined<br />

60 percent of wages and capital. 17<br />

Conceived as a useful commodity, then, New York<br />

by Gehry attains prices and values that govern the relative<br />

upper end of the residential real estate market in large,<br />

wealthy cities like New York. Conceived as capital, however,<br />

New York by Gehry assimilates those prices and values<br />

into an investment designed to profit from the environment<br />

that both Piketty and Stiglitz describe, wherein an increasingly<br />

smaller proportion of the population controls an increasingly<br />

greater proportion of the wealth. As a diagram<br />

of wage inequality, then, New York by Gehry is par for the<br />

course; as a diagram of wealth inequality, it is exemplary.<br />

2.1.3 Surveys and Indexes<br />

Piketty also points out that in the United States,<br />

owning real estate constitutes the primary form of capital<br />

accumulation for about nine of the top 10 percent by<br />

wealth, where, it “accounts for half of total wealth and for<br />

some individuals more than three quarters.” 18 Below that,<br />

the importance of real estate in determining household<br />

wealth is often still greater. While above, in the top 1 percent,<br />

its significance diminishes in relation to securities<br />

and other financial instruments, the importance of which<br />

is near total among the very largest fortunes. To the extent<br />

that its financial performance depends on high earners,<br />

while also contributing to the retirement portfolios<br />

of college professors who invest with TIAA-CREF, and to<br />

the performance of publicly traded shares in Forest City<br />

Enterprises, New York by Gehry operates at both levels.<br />

However, assuming that it is the primary residence<br />

for all 899 of the households it harbors, its residents<br />

occupy a slightly eccentric position relative to the<br />

norms enforced by national policies. According to the<br />

2013 American Housing Survey, of the 115.8 million occupied<br />

housing units nationwide, only about 40 million<br />

were rentals, of which only 880,000 cost $2,500 per<br />

month or more. When the data are divided this way, the<br />

residents of New York by Gehry represent less than 0.1<br />

percent of the general population. This is different than<br />

saying that they are in the top decile of income and are<br />

therefore among the nation’s elites. Instead, it reminds us<br />

that the particular way of life represented by the building<br />

is quite unusual, and would be even more so if we factor<br />

in the relative scarcity of residential rental buildings with<br />

50 or more units, which comprise about 3.5 million total<br />

units. Far more common are the country’s 62.7 million<br />

owner-occupied detached houses. 19 This is no surprise, of<br />

course, since it reflects the widespread patterns of homeownership<br />

that extend well into the lower middle class.<br />

That the data exist in this particular form, however, is<br />

perhaps more telling.<br />

As a technique for governing as well as a basis<br />

for extracting profit, inequality operates according to a<br />

fluid set of rules, categories, and procedures. The most<br />

visible of these (written into the word’s mathematical<br />

connotations) is the act of counting and of measuring. In<br />

the contemporary United States, as elsewhere, although<br />

the individual level has been studied, the basic unit for<br />

generating data on economic inequality remains the<br />

household. 20 Commonly, these data are incorporated into<br />

comparative, macroeconomic quanta such as the Gini<br />

coefficient, which serve as synthetic indexes. The World<br />

Bank, for example, defines its quanta as follows: “[The]<br />

Gini index measures the extent to which the distribution<br />

104 105

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!