31.10.2015 Views

ARCHITECTURE

artofinequality_150917_web

artofinequality_150917_web

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

of income or consumption expenditure among individuals<br />

or households within an economy deviates from a<br />

perfectly equal distribution.” Measured this way, in 2010<br />

(the most complete dataset as of this writing), the United<br />

States had a Gini index of .411, as compared to significantly<br />

lower (and therefore “less unequal”) indexes in Tunisia<br />

(.358), the Slovak Republic (.273), Denmark (.269), and the<br />

United Kingdom (.380), among others. 21<br />

Although it obscures more granular differences,<br />

this tells us that the United States is among the most unequal<br />

of advanced economies. A closer look, however, tells<br />

us more about how such indexes work both to measure<br />

inequality and to reproduce it by providing one way of<br />

calculating the differences that make markets move. Gini<br />

metadata indicate that datasets were drawn from a variety<br />

of national sources, which have been correlated according<br />

to the “central concept of ‘equivalized household disposable<br />

income,’” or, essentially, after-tax income adjusted<br />

for household size. 22 In the case of the United States, these<br />

data were translated from the Annual Social and Economic<br />

Supplement to the Current Population Survey, which is<br />

compiled jointly by the U.S. Census Bureau and the Department<br />

of Labor Statistics. 23 It is based on interviews<br />

with “a probability selected sample of about 60,000 selected<br />

households” that begins with an address and then<br />

sorts for eligibility to exclude vacant units, business, and<br />

other nonresidential addresses. 24 Telephone interviews<br />

are then conducted over a period of four months to determine<br />

and verify household data pertaining to occupancy,<br />

family makeup, employment, and income. 25<br />

In this way the survey, and hence the data, presupposes<br />

and utilizes the basic infrastructure of housing,<br />

including the postal system, the telephone system, and all<br />

of those other systems that combine in the delimitation<br />

and enclosure of the unit itself. Scaling up, the U.S. Current<br />

Population Survey essentially supplements data gathered<br />

via similar methods through the annual American<br />

Community Survey, which samples about 150,000 households.<br />

Most comprehensive of all is the full U.S. Census<br />

conducted every ten years, the most recent of which was<br />

also completed in 2010. 26<br />

From the other direction, data related to housing<br />

stock itself are compiled annually by the Department<br />

of Housing and Urban Development in collaboration with<br />

the U.S. Census Bureau in the American Housing Survey<br />

(AHS). In this case the object of study is the physical “housing<br />

unit” rather than the socioeconomic “household,” with<br />

the aim being to “[ask] questions about the quality of housing<br />

in the United States.” 27 The Census Bureau indicates<br />

that “policy analysts, program managers, budget analysts,<br />

and Congressional staff use AHS data to monitor supply<br />

and demand, as well as changes in housing conditions and<br />

costs, in order to assess housing needs.” 28 Since the vast<br />

majority of public policy related to housing in the United<br />

States is market-based, it quickly becomes clear that the<br />

AHS is, in effect, a market survey that helps to shape, rather<br />

than merely measure, its object of study: the housing<br />

unit. 29 If this is not self-evident, the AHS website makes it<br />

so, when it adds euphemistically that “academic researchers<br />

and private organizations also use AHS data in efforts<br />

of specific interest and concern to their respective communities.”<br />

30 This is another way of illustrating how the AHS<br />

makes itself available to the real estate industry. The maps<br />

of inequality provided by the U.S. Census and the Gini index<br />

correlate with the market surveyed by the AHS. Together,<br />

these point to an important way that lives are governed<br />

where the housing system and the real estate system<br />

meet; where the basic commodity is the housing unit and<br />

where the basic unit of governance is the household.<br />

Tied as it is to the housing unit, the household is<br />

a distinctly infrastructural category that presupposes an<br />

entire urban field. It also presupposes tangible architectur-<br />

106 107

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!