deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of
deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of
deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
4.4.4 Management Interfaces<br />
Management <strong>of</strong> the WDM Network Layer 69<br />
WDM network elements are not tied to any particular management interface;<br />
this is also true for WDM element <strong>and</strong> network management systems. Possible<br />
interfaces may range from proprietary to st<strong>and</strong>ardized interfaces. This section<br />
will describe a set <strong>of</strong> frequently used st<strong>and</strong>ardized interfaces for <strong>managing</strong><br />
WDM network elements. The main management interfaces competing on the<br />
network element layer are TL1, SNMP, <strong>and</strong> common management information<br />
protocol (CMIP). Also Telcordia’s OSMINE is used in <strong>networks</strong> as a means to<br />
communicate between the OSS <strong>and</strong> various types <strong>of</strong> network elements.<br />
Transaction language 1 (TL1) [18] is a text-based, comm<strong>and</strong>-line, telecommunications<br />
protocol for network element management, specified by Bellcore<br />
in 1986. A large number <strong>of</strong> technologies <strong>and</strong> vendors have network<br />
elements that are managed via TL1. General acceptance <strong>of</strong> TL1 was brought<br />
with the reliance <strong>of</strong> operators on Telcordia operation support system (OSSs) for<br />
interfacing with network elements. In today’s large OTNs, TL1 is the dominating<br />
protocol, as SNMP is for packet <strong>networks</strong>.<br />
SNMP is the IETF’s st<strong>and</strong>ardized network management interface <strong>and</strong><br />
dominates the packet <strong>networks</strong>. While the majority <strong>of</strong> the WDM equ<strong>ip</strong>ment<br />
vendors mainly <strong>of</strong>fer a TL1 interface, some do also <strong>of</strong>fer SNMP. However, limited<br />
security [19] is built into SNMP, <strong>and</strong> it is vulnerable to malicious individuals<br />
due to its inconsistent behavior when unexpected input is provided. The OSI<br />
network management model proposes a different approach than the one<br />
described earlier. Manager <strong>and</strong> agent communicate by means <strong>of</strong> the CMIP protocol<br />
[20, 21]. This is an alternative that <strong>of</strong>fers richer functionality than TL1<br />
but is more costly to deploy. Unlike TL1, CMIP <strong>and</strong> SNMP are both based on<br />
platform-centric manager-agent paradigms, each with a different information<br />
model. This is in contrast to TL1, which does not have any information model<br />
concept defined.<br />
Different from the previous models, the OSMINE [1] is a process that,<br />
according to Telcordia, integrates equ<strong>ip</strong>ment manufacturer’s products with Telcordia<br />
OSSs. OSMINE, that is conforming the TL1 interface, gives network<br />
equ<strong>ip</strong>ment interoperability with Telcordia OSS systems. Telcordia <strong>of</strong>fers this<br />
process as a service to optical equ<strong>ip</strong>ment vendors to certify the equ<strong>ip</strong>ment.<br />
Because Telcordia is in a monopolistic position with the regional Bell operating<br />
companies (RBOCS), other vendors’ equ<strong>ip</strong>ment must be made OSMINE compliant.<br />
OSMINE is an ongoing process because Telcordia is the single authority<br />
to determine the scope <strong>of</strong> work for OSMINE certification. Network element<br />
vendors that intend to deploy products at mult<strong>ip</strong>le service providers may be<br />
required to undergo OSMINE certification mult<strong>ip</strong>le times. Sometimes the EMS<br />
or NMS that come with a vendor’s network element must undergo OSMINE<br />
certification also. More<strong>over</strong>, when a new Telcordia OSS system is introduced