15.12.2012 Views

deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of

deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of

deploying and managing ip over wdm networks - Index of

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

4.4.4 Management Interfaces<br />

Management <strong>of</strong> the WDM Network Layer 69<br />

WDM network elements are not tied to any particular management interface;<br />

this is also true for WDM element <strong>and</strong> network management systems. Possible<br />

interfaces may range from proprietary to st<strong>and</strong>ardized interfaces. This section<br />

will describe a set <strong>of</strong> frequently used st<strong>and</strong>ardized interfaces for <strong>managing</strong><br />

WDM network elements. The main management interfaces competing on the<br />

network element layer are TL1, SNMP, <strong>and</strong> common management information<br />

protocol (CMIP). Also Telcordia’s OSMINE is used in <strong>networks</strong> as a means to<br />

communicate between the OSS <strong>and</strong> various types <strong>of</strong> network elements.<br />

Transaction language 1 (TL1) [18] is a text-based, comm<strong>and</strong>-line, telecommunications<br />

protocol for network element management, specified by Bellcore<br />

in 1986. A large number <strong>of</strong> technologies <strong>and</strong> vendors have network<br />

elements that are managed via TL1. General acceptance <strong>of</strong> TL1 was brought<br />

with the reliance <strong>of</strong> operators on Telcordia operation support system (OSSs) for<br />

interfacing with network elements. In today’s large OTNs, TL1 is the dominating<br />

protocol, as SNMP is for packet <strong>networks</strong>.<br />

SNMP is the IETF’s st<strong>and</strong>ardized network management interface <strong>and</strong><br />

dominates the packet <strong>networks</strong>. While the majority <strong>of</strong> the WDM equ<strong>ip</strong>ment<br />

vendors mainly <strong>of</strong>fer a TL1 interface, some do also <strong>of</strong>fer SNMP. However, limited<br />

security [19] is built into SNMP, <strong>and</strong> it is vulnerable to malicious individuals<br />

due to its inconsistent behavior when unexpected input is provided. The OSI<br />

network management model proposes a different approach than the one<br />

described earlier. Manager <strong>and</strong> agent communicate by means <strong>of</strong> the CMIP protocol<br />

[20, 21]. This is an alternative that <strong>of</strong>fers richer functionality than TL1<br />

but is more costly to deploy. Unlike TL1, CMIP <strong>and</strong> SNMP are both based on<br />

platform-centric manager-agent paradigms, each with a different information<br />

model. This is in contrast to TL1, which does not have any information model<br />

concept defined.<br />

Different from the previous models, the OSMINE [1] is a process that,<br />

according to Telcordia, integrates equ<strong>ip</strong>ment manufacturer’s products with Telcordia<br />

OSSs. OSMINE, that is conforming the TL1 interface, gives network<br />

equ<strong>ip</strong>ment interoperability with Telcordia OSS systems. Telcordia <strong>of</strong>fers this<br />

process as a service to optical equ<strong>ip</strong>ment vendors to certify the equ<strong>ip</strong>ment.<br />

Because Telcordia is in a monopolistic position with the regional Bell operating<br />

companies (RBOCS), other vendors’ equ<strong>ip</strong>ment must be made OSMINE compliant.<br />

OSMINE is an ongoing process because Telcordia is the single authority<br />

to determine the scope <strong>of</strong> work for OSMINE certification. Network element<br />

vendors that intend to deploy products at mult<strong>ip</strong>le service providers may be<br />

required to undergo OSMINE certification mult<strong>ip</strong>le times. Sometimes the EMS<br />

or NMS that come with a vendor’s network element must undergo OSMINE<br />

certification also. More<strong>over</strong>, when a new Telcordia OSS system is introduced

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!