Untitled - Smithsonian Institution
Untitled - Smithsonian Institution
Untitled - Smithsonian Institution
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
THOMAS] INDIAN LANGUAGES OF MEXICO AND CENTRAL AMERICA 89<br />
Cabecar, Estrella, Terraba, Tirribi, and Tuciirric; some others are<br />
mentioned which are now extinct. This course has been adopted<br />
for present purposes, for the reason that, while it is possible to outline<br />
with approximate correctness the territory of the group, the data<br />
do not justify the attempt to mark the areas of the separate dialects.<br />
It is necessary to state here that on the present map the southeastern<br />
boundary of Costa Rica, that between this republic and<br />
Panama, is not as given on most maps, but as defined by the President<br />
of France, who was appointed arbiter by the two republics of<br />
the dispute concerning this boundary. By this decision a considerable<br />
strip of southeastern Costa Rica was awarded to Colombia. As<br />
will be seen, part of the Talamancan territory falls within this strip.<br />
It should be stated further that Talamanca is here used as a generic<br />
term for the group and not given to any one dialect. The name has<br />
been very loosely applied; for instance Fernandez (1: 617) says the<br />
"naciones" of the Talamanca are Cabecar, Viceite, Terraba, Toxare,<br />
Changuene, Zegua, Torasque, and Guaymie, thus including tribes of<br />
two different stocks—Chibchan and Nahuatlan (Zegua). It is somewhat<br />
strange that a citizen of the country should have made this<br />
mistake in 1889, especially as Dr. Max Uhle in 1888 (470) gave<br />
correctly, so far ,as his reference extends, the Bribri, Cabecar, Estrella,<br />
Tiribi, and Tucurrique. Moreover, B. A. Thiel in his Apuntos Lexi-<br />
cograficos de las Lenguas, to wdiich Fernandez refers, gives as the<br />
dialects of the Talamanca or Viceite, Bribri, Cabecar, Estrella, and<br />
Chirripo. He mentions Boruca and Terraba separately. Chirripo is<br />
considered by some authorities merely a subdialect of Cabecar; by<br />
others, Tariaca under another name, spoken by the people of a<br />
particular village (5alled Chirripo and the immediately surrounding<br />
region. Sapper (1: 31) says:<br />
The language of Tucurrique or Tucurriqui, a village situated on the banks of the<br />
Rio Reventazon differs only in a few non-essential dialectic details from the language<br />
of the Indians living on the banks of the Rio Chirripo, Rio Estrella, Coen and the upper<br />
Teliri, which Pittier names Cabecara after their chief dwelling place, S. Jose Cabecar.<br />
An examination of the vocabularies given by Thiel tends to confirm<br />
this conclusion. Pittier and Gagini (7) consider three of these dia-<br />
lects the principal ones—Bribri, to which are referred Cabecar, Chir-<br />
ripo, Estrella and Tucurric; Terraba, which is considered identical<br />
with Tirribi; and Boruca, which forms the third division.<br />
According to Peralta's paper quoted above (p. 83), the south-<br />
eastern boundary of the Guetare territory, where it joined the Talamancan<br />
area, extended from the mouth of the Rio Matina westward<br />
to Terrialba on the north line of Cartago district. In his map (Mit-<br />
teilungen, 1901) Sapper locates a small colony of Cabecar in the<br />
northern part of this district, on the extreme headwaters of the Reventazon<br />
river. From this it appears that the northern boundary<br />
8347°—Bull. 44—11 7