26.12.2014 Views

Watershed Conservation Plan - Destination Erie

Watershed Conservation Plan - Destination Erie

Watershed Conservation Plan - Destination Erie

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

with the appearance of European trade goods, such as glass beads or metal items, at Native American sites,<br />

or in the absence of such items, to the terminal sixteenth through early seventeenth centuries.<br />

The approximately 500-600 years of the Late Woodland in the glaciated Allegheny Plateau of<br />

Pennsylvania, including the study area, has been subdivided by Johnson (1999) into three successive phases<br />

comprising what he terms the Glaciated Allegheny Plateau (GAP) tradition. The first GAP phase is termed<br />

the Mahoning phase, and is characterized by pottery that is tempered with igneous rock with cord-marked<br />

exterior surfaces and low collars (Johnson and Myers 2002:5). At approximately A.D. 1250-1275 in<br />

calibrated calendar years, pulverized mussel shell replaces igneous rock as the principal tempering agent for<br />

Mahoning ware, and marks the end of the Mahoning phase (Johnson and Myers 2002:7).<br />

The succeeding French Creek phase is recognizable from ca. A.D. 1275-1400 and is characterized by<br />

Chautauqua Cord-Marked vessels, which are shell-tempered and otherwise undecorated except for cordwrapped<br />

paddle edge-stamped impressions or incisions on vessel lips. During this time, nucleated and<br />

palisaded villages appear within the French Creek valley southeast of the study area at Wilson Shutes<br />

(36CW5) and McFate (36CW1) while small hamlets and/or farmsteads have been identified in the<br />

Pymatuning Marsh immediately to the southwest of the study area (Johnson and Myers 2002:7).<br />

In the initial decades of the fifteenth century (i.e., ca. A.D. 1400 -1425), a distinctive form of ceramics<br />

referred to as McFate Incised appears on the glaciated Allegheny Plateau and the Lake <strong>Erie</strong> Plain to the north<br />

(Johnson and Myers 2002:7). The appearance of this ware marks the final McFate phase of the GAP tradition<br />

which is dated to ca. A.D. 1400-1550. The McFate Incised ceramic type is characterized by rectilinear incised<br />

decoration in the form of opposed triangles filled with parallel horizontal lines separated by plats of parallel<br />

oblique lines (Johnson and Myers 2002:8). This decoration appears below the lip or on the collar of McFate<br />

vessels. The base of the motif is frequently underlined with a horizontal band of parallel oblique or vertical<br />

punctations or short incised lines (Johnson and Myers 2002:8). The McFate decorative motif is similar to the<br />

late Middleport horizon Ontario Iroquoian tradition ceramic types Pound Blank and Huron Incised, and<br />

Johnson argues that the genesis of McFate pottery was apparently on the Lake <strong>Erie</strong> Plain (Johnson 1999:8).<br />

McFate Incised and related ceramic types have a rather broad distribution perhaps reflecting population<br />

movement and/or economic cooperation between neighboring groups (Johnson and Myers 2002:7). McFate<br />

phase components are documented at sites along the Lake <strong>Erie</strong> Plain from northeast Ohio to Chautauqua<br />

County, New York. These include the East Wall site (33AB41), a multi-component, primarily Ontario<br />

Iroquoian tradition and McFate phase fishing station dating to A.D. 1448 that overlooks the confluence of<br />

Conneaut Creek and Lake <strong>Erie</strong> in Ashtabula County, Ohio, and the Westfield-Mac (30CH1) and Silverheels<br />

sites in New York (Johnson 1999:7). The Wintergreen Gorge site (36ER6), located just south of the lake plain<br />

along the Portage Escarpment near <strong>Erie</strong>, Pennsylvania, is a McFate phase village dated to as late as ca. A.D.<br />

1468–1623.<br />

By the final decades of the fourteenth century A.D., McFate culture had spread south to sites on the<br />

glaciated Allegheny Plateau. Nucleated, palisaded McFate villages occur on the glaciated Allegheny Plateau<br />

in the French Creek valley and include the continued occupation of sites such as McFate (36CW1) and<br />

Wilson Shutes (36CW5). The McFate type site is the earliest dated McFate site on the Plateau, with an<br />

occupation range of A.D. 1410–1435 suggested by AMS dates derived from carbonized organic residue from<br />

the interiors of two rim sherds (Johnson 1999:7). McFate phase stockaded hunting villages are reported along<br />

Pymatuning Marsh as well as in the interior unglaciated Allegheny Plateau, and numerous small open air and<br />

rockshelter McFate sites are found in the Geneva Marsh area and again, in the interior unglaciated Allegheny<br />

Plateau (Johnson and Myers :9).<br />

There seems to have been a gradual dispersal of McFate phase people from the glaciated Allegheny<br />

Plateau by the mid- to late fifteenth century (Johnson and Myers 2002:10). Indeed, the glaciated reaches of<br />

the Allegheny Plateau in northwestern Pennsylvania, including the study area, seem to have been largely<br />

abandoned by village horticulturalists by the beginning of the sixteenth century, perhaps in response to the<br />

colder, drier conditions of the Neo-Boreal climatic episode. The deteriorating climatic conditions of the Neo-<br />

Boreal may well have rendered a maize-based subsistence strategy unreliable, at best, in northwestern<br />

Pennsylvania (Richardson et al. 2002; Johnson and Myers 2002:10). Around this time, McFate phase ceramic<br />

vessels—and, presumably, their makers—spread across the unglaciated reaches of that province in northcentral<br />

Pennsylvania to the headwaters of the West Branch of the Susquehanna (Johnson 1999:7). In this latter<br />

26

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!