Safety in the vicinity of non-towered aerodromes - Australian ...

In February 2002, a Cessna 172 Skyhawk aircraft and a TL Sting ultralight converged and
collided at low altitude in the vicinity of the threshold of runway 24 right at Jandakot
Aerodrome, WA. Both aircraft were attempting to land at the time of the accident. The
occupants of both aircraft were uninjured, but the TL Sting was substantially damaged and
the Cessna sustained minor damage.
Jandakot Tower was active until a short time before the collision, and both aircraft had
conducted their arrival to the aerodrome under General Aviation Aerodrome Procedures
(GAAP). The GAAP control zone was deactivated at the scheduled time (1800 local time),
and the aircraft were operating under MBZ procedures for the final stages of their flights.
At the time of the collision, a CA/GRS operator was providing operational information to
pilots. Although the CA/GRS used the facilities of the control tower to provide this service,
this did not include any function of air traffic control.
The investigation by the ATSB determined that the pilot of the Cessna had probably sighted
the wrong aircraft to follow when provided with sequencing instructions by the aerodrome
controller. The pilot of the Cessna did not see the TL Sting during his base and final
approach. This task was made more difficult by a number of factors, including the lack of
contrast between the TL Sting and the background terrain, the relative position between the
two aircraft during the final stages of the approach, and possibly the effects of sun glare.
This was compounded by the pilot's perception that the aircraft ahead had already landed. A
short time after the collision, the aerodrome operator withdrew the CA/GRS service. The
tower operator subsequently reviewed the provision of air traffic services, and extended
tower hours of operation.
Source: ATSB, 2004
- 55 -