3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

11615:20:461 of this particular lodgement, is because you don't want to be seen to be taking2 a different stance than you took on a previous occasion, do you understand?3 Which isn't a very good reason for taking that position. And it could, and it4 has very serious consequences for you, given that you are giving evidence under15:21:115 oath. Do you understand?67 What you have effectively said in reply to Mr. O'Neill a few moments ago was,8 or is, that because you took a particular stance on the last occasion, maybe9 genuinely so, I mean, I'm not suggesting that it automatically follows that you15:21:3810 were lying on a previous occasion. But because you took a position the last11 time, that you are now -- that you are going to stand over that position even12 given the evidence that we see.13 A. The evidence that I see, Judge Mahon, remains on it.1415:21:4915 CHAIRMAN: Well your name, your address.16 A. Yes.1718 CHAIRMAN: The name of the account holder.19 A. Yes.15:21:542021 CHAIRMAN: Yes.22 A. I have no recollections of Sterling.2324 JUDGE FAHERTY: And coupled, just to add to the Chairman, with your previous15:22:0225 testimony that you were the only person who made lodgements to the accounts of26 Cecelia and Georgina Ahern?27 A. Yes.2829 JUDGE FAHERTY: Isn't that correct?15:22:0930 A. Yes.Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839