3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

6412:53:161 Q. 443 So is it your evidence now that you didn't prepare that at all?2 A. No.3 Q. 444 You didn't?4 A. I didn't.12:53:245 Q. 445 So who prepared it?6 A. That's the information that I got. I mean I had to get this information from7 the Irish Permanent.8 Q. 446 Okay.9 A. The information was on there.12:53:3310 Q. 447 You are the man would is up there giving evidence on oath. Is that information11 true or not true?12 A. It is true that the money was Sterling was purchased in, yes.13 Q. 448 Do you know --14 A. 3,000.12:53:4815 Q. 449 Do you know from your own knowledge if anything in this is accurate or16 inaccurate from your own knowledge? Not from what other people have told you.17 Do you know?18 A. Well I wouldn't know, no.19 Q. 450 So you don't know. So of all of the evidence that you have given here today,12:54:0320 what bits of it are we supposed to believe or what bits of it should with we21 not believe?22 A. I was confirming that the documentation had gone through the branch at the23 time.24 Q. 451 No, no, no with respect. You say "there was a purchase of 4,000 pounds12:54:1725 Sterling on the 28th of October at 16:43 in the branch" so what you should have26 said was I've been shown some documents which show that there was, isn't that27 correct?282912:54:2930 MR. HOLLAND: Sir, I must intervene.Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839