3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

12415:34:571 have given them to me then.2 Q: I think he was actually paid every two weeks but I'm subject to correction3 on that, but your recollection is that it was a monthly payment?4 A: Monthly.15:35:065 Q: Okay. But if it was every two weeks what you are clear about is that you6 only did it once a month so he may well have cheque given you two cheques once7 a month?8 A: I don't recall. I just remember it being every month."915:35:2310 Judge Keys asked you on the same day at page 169, 802 "Just one question. Do I11 take it from your evidence that the only banking input you had with Mr. Ahern12 was related purely to his cheques arising from his salary, is that correct?13 A: Yes, Judge.14 Q: Nothing else?15:35:4615 A: Nothing else, Judge".1617 Do we take it from that, Ms. Carruth, that until that point, day 802, you were18 making no reference to the fact that you were in fact making lodgements to19 Mr. Ahern's own accounts, isn't that so?15:36:0320 A. Yes.21 Q. 684 And why is it that you did not indicate to the Tribunal at that time that not22 only were you engaged in cashing his cheques and bringing the money back to23 him, you were also engaged in making lodgements to his bank account?24 A. I don't remember. I didn't remember at the time that he had a bank account --15:36:2825 an Irish Permanent account.26 Q. 685 Well had you not discuss this had with Mr. Ahern before the responses were27 given by him to the Tribunal as to what accounts he had and what lodgements28 were made to them, did he not discuss that with you?29 A. No.15:36:4630 Q. 686 We'll see from page 27293, the next lodgement in sequence to the IPBS accountPremier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839