3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

12915:44:491 we were given no opportunity.2 CHAIRMAN: But you were also invited to make a, to submit a narrative3 statement which could have been done.415:44:585 MR. MILLAR: I have addressed that with the Tribunal's solicitors. That I6 didn't have an opportunity to do that.78 CHAIRMAN: All right.915:45:0310 MR. MILLAR: So I think it's unfair to categorise it in that way that11 Ms. Carruth refused or didn't bother. That is not the case.1213 JUDGE KEYS: Can you recollect what you said in your letter to the Tribunal.1415:45:1515 MR. MILLAR: Do you recollect?1617 MR. MILLAR: Absolutely I do, yes.1819 JUDGE KEYS: Standing by the answers which you gave to my questions.15:45:232021 MR. MILLAR: Yes.2223 JUDGE KEYS: She already having all of the documentation which has been put24 before her now.15:45:282526 MR. MILLAR: I absolutely recollect it. The reality of the situation is after27 14 years --2829 JUDGE KEYS: What's unfair it about it?15:45:3730Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839