3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

12615:39:111 deliberate on it and to come in to give evidence in relation to your evidence2 on this particular transaction?3 A. Yes.4 Q. 695 You have had a whole series. In fact, you've had every document that was15:39:235 considered this morning in evidence before you. And there are obvious6 conclusions which anybody could draw from the sequencing of the transactions7 and from your signature to various documents, isn't that right?8 A. Yes.9 Q. 696 Is it going to be the case that your response to every question on detail is15:39:4410 that you cannot recollect and you cannot remember?11 A. I can't remember, sorry. It's 14 years ago. I can't remember back that long.1213 JUDGE FAHERTY: Mrs. Carruth, on a previous occasion you had recollection of14 bringing cash back to Mr. Ahern.15:40:0315 A. Yes.1617 JUDGE FAHERTY: And leaving it either in a drawer on or handing it to him on18 occasions in respect of you cashing his cheques, isn't that correct and you had19 memory of that?15:40:1320 A. Yes.2122 JUDGE FAHERTY: And really what Mr. O'Neill is asking you. Is how is it that23 you don't have recollection or memory of doing the opposite, going with cash at24 the behest of Mr. Ahern and lodging it?15:40:2725 A. My memory at that time was just dealing on his cheque and then going to Irish26 Permanent.27 Q. 697 MR. O'NEILL: You were asked in the course of interview with the Tribunal in28 June of 2006, I beg your pardon. 6th of July 2006 at page 17935, question 33.2915:41:0330 "In relation to other transactions were you ever requested by Mr. Ahern toPremier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839