3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

12815:43:181 of weeks. And I presume if it's her position now, as it appears to be, that2 information previously given to the Tribunal under oath was incorrect, that3 that should have been corrected before now.415:43:355 MR. MILLAR: Well I think with respect, she has offered an explanation for6 that. She did not recollect this at all. It has been put to her that she did7 recollect and this is as an implication of the Tribunal's questions, she did8 recollect it but she is only admitting it now. That is not what she said.915:43:4910 CHAIRMAN: Ms. Carruth accepts now that these transactions were conducted by11 her.1213 MR. MILLAR: Yeah on the face of documentation that's been put in front of14 her, yes.15:43:581516 CHAIRMAN: Well it's been put in front of her over the last week or two weeks.1718 MR. MILLAR: Oh, absolutely. But it wasn't put in front of her when she was19 here in December when the questions were posed by Judge Keys.15:44:092021 CHAIRMAN: I'm just saying the position. If these helped her recollect or22 accept that the position is different to that already given, I am just23 suggesting to you that the appropriate thing to have done was to have24 corrected, to have sought to correct the record in the last week or two weeks.15:44:312526 MR. MILLAR: Well, Mr. Chairman, I have been in communication with the27 Tribunal about this. We were asked to attend a meeting at less than 12 hours28 notice when I wasn't at work. When the Tribunal were advised that I wasn't29 there at all. We were then asked. That was on a Friday. We were then asked15:44:4430 to attend at 12 o'clock on Monday. I didn't see the letter until Monday. SoPremier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839