3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

6712:58:181 concerned that this witness is being examined as if he had made a claim which2 in fact he has not made.34 I think the Tribunal may have already appreciated the sooner remark made a12:58:295 moment ago. He is being cross-examined as if in some way he is claiming to6 have had personal knowledge of large numbers of these transactions.78 CHAIRMAN: No. I think he has made it clear that he based his evidence on, to9 a large extent, documentation which he assumes is accurate.12:58:49101112 MR. HOLLAND: That's precisely the case. I am much obliged.1314 MR. MILLAR: I think it would also be fair to say, Mr. Chairman, that he has12:58:5815 made an assertion that he recalls my client conducting the Sterling16 transactions in the branch.1718 CHAIRMAN: Absolutely. Yes. His evidence was. But he can't recall any19 specific transaction that Ms. Carruth was involved in. But he does recall her12:59:1220 engaging in some Sterling transaction or actions I'm not quite certain whether21 it's more than one.2223 Q. 453 MR. MILLAR: Very good.24 I am going to be another few minutes, Mr. Chairman, I don't know if you wish to12:59:2625 break. It's one o'clock -- or keep going.2627 CHAIRMAN: All right. We'll break until two o'clock.2829 MR. MILLAR: Very good.12:59:3330Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839