3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

6212:48:011 A. Yeah.2 Q. 432 So is there a possibility at all that what you've said here at private3 interview is wrong?4 A. Well let's see the documents.12:48:035 Q. 433 I'm just asking?6 A. To comment before I would like to see the document.7 Q. 434 You see, Mr. Hughes, we have to prepare these cases to ask questions of you and8 we have done a lot on the particular assumption that what you've said here is9 accurate. So what I want to know is before you look at the documentation, are12:48:2010 you satisfied what you said already in private interview which has been11 circulated to all of us is accurate or not.12 A. Based on the information that I had, to my knowledge, it was accurate.13 Q. 435 But this is critical, Mr. Hughes, this is --14 A. I would like to see the documents to confirm that.12:48:361516 CHAIRMAN: Sorry, Mr. Millar, if he is to answer that question, is it possible17 that he was wrong in the, in the what he said at private interview. He is18 going to have to see the documentation because presumably that will tell him19 whether what he said at the time.12:48:552021 MR. MILLAR: Absolutely, Chairman. I have no problem with that.2223 CHAIRMAN: So can we have hard copies of ...2412:49:0225 MR. MILLAR: Sorry, I don't have hard copies.2627 CHAIRMAN: No, no. I know you don't. Do the bank have hard copies?282912:49:1530 MR. HOLLAND: Sir, we have a copy of the lodgement form, just for the record ofPremier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839