3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

12715:41:071 lodge cash to any account from the safe?2 A: No." Do you accept now that that is incorrect?3 A. Yes.4 Q. 698 In giving your evidence on day 802, Ms. Carruth, at page 169 you were15:41:485 questioned by Judge Keys about the extent of your banking transactions for6 Mr. Ahern as follows.78 "I take it then from your evidence that the only banking input with Mr. Ahern9 was related purely to his cheques arising from his salary, is that correct?15:42:0910 A: Yes, Judge.11 Q: Nothing else?12 A: Nothing else, Judge.13 Q: Never asked to lodge monies, change currency or anything like that?14 A: No. "15:42:201516 That is now untrue, isn't that right, Ms. Carruth?17 A. It appears that way.18 Q. 699 Well what's the explanation for that, Ms. Carruth? Is it the case that until19 such time as uncontrovertible evidence is laid before you, that you are15:42:5020 prepared to deny that you were involved in the matter. And when the evidence21 is put before you, your response is to indicate that you simply cannot22 recollect.2324 MR. MILLAR: Sorry, Mr. Chairman, I object to the manner in which way that15:43:0325 question was posed. I mean the witness has said that it was 14 years ago and26 she does not recollect this at all.2728 MR. O'NEILL: I would like to continue my examination without interruption.2915:43:1230 CHAIRMAN: Perfectly -- Ms. Carruth has had this information now for a couplePremier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839