3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

13015:45:371 MR. MILLAR: What's unfair about it, Judge, is that categorising it in such a2 way that this witness is simply saying now that she recollects issue but that3 she is only being put to the pin of her collar to do so and that she was4 conceding the truth. That's what is unfair about it.15:45:4656 JUDGE KEYS: Why do you have to be put to the pin of your collar before you7 concede anything?89 MR. MILLAR: But that,s exactly the point, Judge Keys. You are making the15:45:5310 point that I am complaining about.1112 JUDGE KEYS: All I can say is that when she got the documentation. All your13 client had to do was to look at the documentation. She could have made a14 greater effort to try and recollect what exactly went on in this period of time15:46:0615 and in light of what she said now, could have gone to you and said listen, I16 think I'm wrong in the manner in which I answered the questions raised by me.17 And I have written in in advance and said in a normal narrative statement or at18 least put the Tribunal on notice that your client is not standing by exactly19 her answers which she has given to so far to the Tribunal.15:46:312021 MR. MILLAR: Judge, these issues came up for the first occasion. The last of22 this documentation arrived in my office last Friday. We have dealt with this23 matter expeditiously. And I object to the implied criticism that Ms. Carruth24 should have come running in here two weeks ago saying I got it wrong. We are15:46:4925 here within a very short period of time of getting this documentation at all.2627 JUDGE KEYS: All we want is the truth. That's what we're looking for.2829 MR. MILLAR: I object to the implication that my client is not telling the15:46:5930 truth or has not told the truth.Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839